Renewables' deep-sea mining conundrum
British scientists exploring an underwater mountain in the Atlantic Ocean have discovered a treasure trove of rare minerals.
Their investigation of a seamount more than 500km (300 miles) from the Canary Islands has revealed a crust of "astonishingly rich" rock.
Samples brought back to the surface contain the scarce substance tellurium in concentrations 50,000 times higher than in deposits on land.
Tellurium is used in a type of advanced solar panel, so the discovery raises a difficult question about whether the push for renewable energy may encourage mining of the seabed.
The rocks also contain what are called rare earth elements that are used in wind turbines and electronics.
Known as Tropic Seamount, the mountain stands about 3,000m tall – about the size of one of the middle-ranging Alpine summits – with a large plateau at its top, lying about 1,000m below the ocean surface.
Using robotic submarines, researchers from the UK's National Oceanography Centre found that the crust is dark and fine-grained and stretches in a layer roughly 4cm thick over the entire surface of the mountain.
Dr Bram Murton, the leader of the expedition, told the BBC that he had been expecting to find abundant minerals on the seamount but not in such concentrations.
"These crusts are astonishingly rich and that's what makes these rocks so incredibly special and valuable from a resource perspective."
He has calculated that the 2,670 tonnes of tellurium on this single seamount represents one-twelfth of the world's total supply.
And Dr Murton has come up with a hypothetical estimate that if the entire deposit could be extracted and used to make solar panels, it could meet 65% of the UK's electricity demand.
He says he is not advocating deep-sea mining, which has yet to start anywhere in the world and is likely to be highly controversial because of the damage it could cause to the marine environment.
But Dr Murton does want his team's discovery, part of a major research project called MarineE-Tech, to trigger a debate about where vital resources should come from.
"If we need green energy supplies, then we need the raw materials to make the devices that produce the energy so, yes, the raw materials have to come from somewhere.
"We either dig them up from the ground and make a very large hole or dig them from the seabed and make a comparatively smaller hole.
"It's a dilemma for society - nothing we do comes without a cost."
Scientists are now weighing up the relative risks and merits of mining on land as opposed to on the seabed.
Weather Today 650
- Helicopter makes emergency landing 3807
- President in Ratnapura 3297
- Flood victims left in hunger – Rajapaksa 3023
- Death toll reaches 180 and 109 missing 2988
- ‘MORA’ blows over to Bangladesh 3854
- Schools in 8 Districts closed till 2 June 2989
- Women go into labour in Chopper 2988
- Life jackets for those in flood-prone areas 2983
- Capt Cool assures an undisrupted fuel supply 2979
- Fear of the FCID 2986
- Obtaining MC services through 2976
- Ex-TNA MP Vinayagamoorthy passes away 2994
- Two loan schemes for flood victims 2988
- Army on vigil at Panapitiya Dam 3633
- Power outage in affected areas 2977
- Northern students pay tribute to flood victims 2988
- Floods and the deterioration of the State 4353
- What’s gone wrong with Indonesia’s democracy? 2972
- Floods, a Curse on Govt – ven.Gnanasara 4292
- India sends second relief ship 3249
- Flood Aid Appeal by Chandima.. 3248
- Navy Task Force removes Wakwella bottleneck 3562
- Schools In Ratnapura, Nivithigala Zones closed 4002
- Bridge Blockage Worsens Gin Ganga Flood threat 3278
- Rough weather to continue 4059
- A calculated & subtle switch from Ports to Petroleum 3449
- Asia centric foreign policy extended to southern Antipodes 2562
- Govt comes in for a lot of flak 2210
- Exploitation in state and private sectors 1914
- A time of gifts Increasing intensity 1862
- India win on D/L method 2753
- No India-Pakistan bilateral series 2746
- I had to change something, says Djokovic 2750
- Top seed Kerber knocked out 2746
- Ferrari clearly favouring Vettel, says Hamilton 2751
- WPNA Netball tourney on 1 July 3138
- Antonians clinch Plate C’ship 2749
- Dixon lucky to walk away alive 3591
- National athletes severely affected by floods 4151
- All Blacks suffer double injury blow 2878
- A HUGE ACHIEVEMENT FOR COUNTRY’S PROGRESS 2668
- Good governance through electoral reforms 2662
- Floods cause havoc 3742
- Rice mafia controls prices 3364
- ‘Yahapalanaya’ an utter failure – People 3192
- LANKAN POLITICS AND SCIENCE LIKE OIL AND WATER! 3304
- China’s long-term plan in Lanka – Carl Zha 3440
- My life is under threat 3203
- BPPL Holdings’ Net Profit up 42% to Rs 436 million 2314
- Expolanka posts Rs 63B revenue 2316
- CBSL prints money as predicted 2420
- Shares hit near two-week low 2320
- SriLankan to fly to Melbourne nonstop 2322
- Over-regulation stunting shipping development 2336
- Cigarette pricing hurting farmers 2322
- LAUGFS PLANS $150-$200M 2330
- E-SIGNATURE ESSENTIAL TO BOOST EXPORTS 2314
- Relaunch of SonicWall 2314
- Ladies College U-17 team emerge TT champions 2254
- Is Constitution the answer? 1788
- Traps from different quarters 1637
- Bahubali 2: Conclusion 392
- RE-ANIMATOR (1985) 579
- Ghost net sculptures 466
- Walking through the Graveyard of “Disruptive Innovation” Failures 396
- Is Milk really necessary for children? 1155
- Mars into Gemini Challenging period to the government 1925
- Third House Denotes Siblings 1906
- Professions signified by planetary combinations 1909
- SADI SATI OF SATURN OR SHANI ERASHTAKA- 2 1891
- Illnesses indicated by horoscope 1886
- Spiritual mine fields sprawl across Paradise 4199
- ‘Soul’, an evening of original music 2997
- Latest play by Inter Act Art 3007
- From Parents’ Perspective 3916
- Saadaya Maarai Salli Hamarai 3011
- Poetry and Picturesqueness 2982
- One country.Nine Days 1009
- A very successful apple dansala 816
- Zero is here 811
- Second mommy and me cook-off winners crowned 804
- Style and sensibility 796
- A titillating curtain-raiser 796