Sri Lanka’s taxation at a glance
with Umesh Moramudali
Tax is often considered one of those evil words that scare people. When I hear the word tax, I used to recall how much hate the Sheriff of Nottingham in Robin Hood inspired for collecting tax from the people and making them miserable. However, as I grew up, I was made to understand that tax is an essential part of everyone's life for the simple reason that it is the major source of government revenue which provides for public amenities.
In recent past, as the new Inland Revenue Bill was presented to the Parliament, the talks about taxation were renewed. For many Sri Lankans, just like I used to think in my childhood, tax brings fear. People are afraid to be taxed and it is very rare to meet someone who appreciates the importance of taxation.
Given the significance of taxation and the vital role it plays in any economy, father of capitalism, Adam Smith specified four major principles of taxation. Those are named Canon of Equity, Canon of Certainty, Canon of Convenience and Canon of Economy.
Canon of equity refers to the importance of taxing citizens based on their ability to pay. In other words, those who earn more should pay higher amounts of tax. In the words of Adam Smith "The subjects of every State ought to contribute towards the support of the government, as nearly as possible, in proportion to their respective abilities, that is, in proportion to their revenue which they respectively enjoy under the protection of the State."
Canon of Certainty refers to the certainty of the amount of tax paid by the individual, when and how. It further implies the importance of a certain method to pay tax. Canon of Convenience or Ease dictates, the tax payer should be able to pay the tax without much hassle. Canon of Economy refers to the minimization of expenditure in the tax collecting process, emphasizing the need for efficiency in collecting tax.
Taxation in Sri Lanka has a number of issues. Major concerns regarding taxation of Sri Lanka are threefold. One is that the tax revenue is extremely low as a percentage of the GDP, second, country's tax structure is extremely complex, making it cumbersome and hectic for tax payers and the third concerns composition, as majority of the tax revenue is generated through indirect taxes such as Value Added Tax (VAT)
Low tax revenue
Over the years, country's tax revenue has been declining as a percentage of the GDP and by now the tax revenue to GDP ratio in Sri Lanka is one of the lowest in the globe. ln 2014, it was as low as 11.6% of the GDP, although there was a sharp rise of tax revenue during the last two years, which resulted in increasing tax revenue to GDP up to 14.3% by 2016.
The country's tax revenue to GDP ratio was as high as 20% during mid 1990s. It was 19.7% in 1993 and increased to 20.5% in 1995. However, ever since then it was consistently declining at a substantial rate and by 2003 it had dropped to 15.7%.
Let alone developed countries, which has tax to GDP ratios exceeding 30% (In Denmark tax revenue to GDP ratio is 46.6%), the Lanka figure is very low even comparing with the countries in the region. In order to maintain expenditure level around 20% without sustaining a budget deficit, the tax revenue needs to be increased.
Composition of tax
One of the serious problems regarding taxation in Sri Lanka is the composition of tax. More than 80% of the tax revenue is generated through indirect taxes which violates the fundamental tax principle of equity. In the case of a country having a colossal amount of indirect tax, every citizen pays the same amount of taxes despite their income or ability to pay tax.
It appears that things had got worse for Sri Lanka over the last two decades. According to the IPS State of the Economy Report 1994, nearly 45% of the tax revenue was generated through indirect taxes in 1994. By now, the figure has risen above 80% subsequent to the introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST) which later was replaced by VAT. By 2016, VAT amounted to 17% of the total tax revenue. During 1971-1975, tax on goods and services amounted to 28% of total revenue, and the figure has soared to 46% during the period 2011-2015.
Need to increase tax net and informal sector
Although GDP has grown over the years, the number of direct tax payers has not increased correspondingly. That has resulted in the stagnation of tax base which is the major reason for the inability of the government to increase direct tax revenue.
One of the major reasons for the inability to increase the tax base is the strong presence of the informal sector. According to the Department of Statistics, nearly 60% of the labour force is in the informal sector, making it impossible to tax the income as such, income is not recorded officially. For example, as per new amendments, a person who earns more than Rs 100,000 per month who is in the formal sector will be liable to pay Pay As You Earn (PAYE), while a person who is in the informal sector who may earn more than Rs 100,000 will not be liable for PAYE.
Complex tax system
Another concern is the complex nature of taxation in the country. There are too many types of taxes and duties in Sri Lanka. That makes it very difficult for the tax payers and acts as a barrier to business facilitation due to cumbersome process. For example, there are certain para tariffs such as Port and Airport Levy (PAL) which make the import process more complex. It is proposed to implement a uniform tariff at a higher rate making the process more simple, instead of making people pay tax for importing the same item several times.
Regarding VAT, at present there are over 150 exemptions as mentioned earlier, making the concept of tax on value addition ineffective. Ideally there should be only a single rate as multiple rates tend to make the system complicated. Therefore the situation that prevailed, with distinct rates for standard goods / services, luxuries and essentials, is not advisable.
CBSL Annual Report 2016 notes that in order to rectify the structural weaknesses persistent in the government budget during the recent past, the government committed to a revenue based fiscal consolidation process, rather than merely pursuing expenditure cuts.
"Although the declining trend in the revenue to GDP ratio observed during the recent past, which is a key concern on the fiscal front, was reversed in 2015, further measures were warranted to maintain this momentum on a sustainable basis, given the issues in the country's tax system. Accordingly, several reforms were undertaken during the year to streamline and simplify the tax system, broaden the tax base, rationalize tax exemptions and concessions, and strengthen tax administration. The measures taken during the year included the Value Added Tax (VAT) rate hike, removal of several exemptions granted on VAT and Nation Building Tax (NBT), broadening of the VAT base by introducing new items into the tax net, reducing the threshold level of NBT, rationalization of incentives granted through the Board of Investment (BOI), upward rate revisions of other taxes, such as Economic Service Charge (ESC), and the removal of exemptions granted under several taxes," Annual report notes.
It was further revealed that during the year, by regulating tax audits, undisclosed income and turnover amounting to Rs 225,424 million could be taxed. Additional taxes imposed during the year based on that were Rs 17,023 million. Actions and steps for recovery of tax have been taken continuously as stipulated in respective enactments in addition to the Default Tax Recovery Act. The Committee for Interpretation of Tax Laws issued interpretations on 38 cases during the year, in addition to necessary guidelines and instructions on certain provisions of the legislation.
Umesh holds a B.A. (Hons) in Economics from the University of Colombo and can be contacted via [email protected]
Lanka Private Bus Owners’ Association President says Bus lanes are good but more needs to be done
Mahinda Rajapaksa :I did my best for the CountrySays Constitution allows him to become Prime Minister
- No free passes to prison hospital in future 1092
- Appoint honourable trustees to govern! 3262
- Nabbed with Kerala Ganja 3116
- Dengue eradication week on MoH deploys 3,000 teams this time 3418
- Badulla gets clean drinking water 3125
- Boost imports to grow – Harsha 3129
- Govt expects to generate Rs 103.8B from tobacco tax 3171
- British HC in C’bo celebrates Britain’s creative industries 3173
- Zoo to open at night 3120
- Anti-SAITM protests GMOA at it again! 3131
- CEB strike ends 3128
- Ranil May Implement Ease Of Doing Business Act 3124
- LG and PC polls before 31 March 2018 – PM 3113
- PC Elections Bill Party leaders decide to go ahead Amendments need not be reviewed – Speaker 3114
- President Sirisena meets Pakistani PM Expresses gratitude for support 3109
- Treasury Bonds Auction probe Mahendran not outside law of country – PCoI 3113
- 3rd stage of the Central Expressway project Signing with Taisei Corporation next week 3109
- Treasury Bonds Auction probe Cross Examination of Mahendran delayed Oral testimony inadequate material documentary evidence sought 3114
- Implementing UN Resolutions President urges Intl Community to be patient 3183
- AG probes SLLRDC tender process Irregularities running into billions 3113
- WIKIPEDIA AND the INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPER OF UK HIGHLIGHTS NOSTRADAMUS’S 11 SHOCKINGLY ACCURATE PREDICTIONS 3048
- The privatization panacea 3025
- National Economy Rice Cultivation in a National Master Plan 3034
- Anti-SAITM forces and the rule of law 3106
- The March of Folly Promoting Amity, 15 years late 2840
- Sri Lanka secure World Cup berth 3025
- ‘Prima Champions Cup’ U-15 Inter Provincial Cricket Chamindu makes first ton of tournament 3029
- Rain threatens second ODI 3032
- Singer – MCA Premier League 2018 Udawatte ton helps MAS 3028
- Not in a bad place with my captaincy: Smith 3031
- Muguruza crushes Puig to advance in Tokyo 3027
- All rounder Boyagoda leads Trinity 3016
- New Head Quarters for ACUSL 3014
- City, United seize title spotlight 3012
- Sri Lanka schools mini marathons Second edition on 23 September 3014
- Within the arc of Chinese influence 3158
- Big Ivan – Russia’s Bang! 2327
- Sri Lanka is a stable country now 2805
- Heading Hybrid Renewable Energy Lights Up Eluvaithivu Island 2918
- ‘Capacity To Pay’, ‘Ability To Pay’ Govt’s New Rates Question Tax Principles 3650
- I will take legal action against ‘footnote’ accusations – Sujeewa Senasinghe 2738
- We are making plans to topple the Government 3786
- We will not support the 20th Amendment – Suresh Premachandran 3114
- Lanka Private Bus Owners’ Association President says Bus lanes are good but more needs to be done 2914
- SF’s vitriolic attack on Bhikkhus prompts Ven. Gunawansa’s foray into politics 4036
- Consumer durable market to recover in 2018 1Q – Singer 3137
- Fitch affirms Alliance Finance at BB+(lka); Withdraws ratings 3113
- Fitch rates LB Finance PLC’s senior and subordinated debt 3115
- Chevron props economic growth through exports to Pakistan 3126
- Fitch rates Sampath Bank’s Basel III Sub Debt ‘A(lka) (EXP) 3115
- Elephant House launches Lemoki 3128
- LMD names TRIAD ‘Most Respected Advertising Company’ 3105
- Maggi noodles now with enhanced flavours 3106
- Russia’s interesting new oil geopolitics 3108
- Fed pressing button to unwind quantitative easing 3103
- Executing an Executive order 2744
- What are The Best Laxative Foods? 2551
- YOU CAN’T JUDGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER 3588
- NASA's spacecraft makes death plunge into Saturn 2484
- Latest addition to the iphone family 2482
- best workout songs 1823
- BOUNCE BACK: AN OPEN MIC 1943
- Cosplayer fame 2197
- Astrological clue to the nature of your progeny 2416
- Vasu Defects that Affect Business Places 2405
- Venus the planet of love 2407
- Egypt before Pharaohs: When Gods ruled the Earth 2379
- Omens connected with muscle twitching 2368
- Body of the Text 3077
- Academic approaches to peace building and reconciliation 3091
- Insights into the life of remarkable missionary 3122
- Theatre Critics 3046
- Jaffna International Cinema Festival 2017 (JaffnaICF 2017) 3067
- Grammar through Literature and A Thousand Voiced Choir 3046
- Animals in thirst 2727
- Enhancing life to the very end 2745
- Hearts break in silence 2733
- Awards for alumni at ‘the best school of all’ 2709
- Blue sky in warm champagne 2704
- A will of steel 2702