Rethink Tax Policy
Rising income disparities are more worrying to the UN than 'climate change,' former UN Conference for Trade and Development Secretary General and Thai Premier Dr. Supachai Panitchpakdi speaking at a function organized by the Sri Lanka Retailers' Association in Colombo, yesterday, said.
He said that the effect of this was that those who invest in real estate, bonds and equities, find their income levels rising faster. This is what led to the Arab Spring, Wall Street Protest and the rise in nationalism in France, which previously was able to garner 1-2% of the vote, but which has since increased to 10%.
Panitchpakdi also said, that though Sri Lanka's retail sales to GDP ratio at 13-15% of GDP were higher than Indonesia or Malaysia and slightly less than Thailand's, its household consumption to GDP ratio was however low, a sign that income disparities were increasing.
His message was that rising income disparities lead to political instability with grave consequences.
The fact that income disparities in Sri Lanka were rising was also highlighted by ADB's Chief Economist Tadateru Hayashi at a press conference in Colombo, recently. He said, that with a Gini coefficient of 0.46% it showed that income disparities were increasing. He however, said that this was normal for a low middle income country transforming itself to a high middle income country.
Premier Ranil Wickremesinghe speaking at a World Bank forum in Colombo last year said, that to minimize income disparities, his Government planned to lower indirect taxes from the current 80% to 60%, while increasing direct taxes from 20% to 40%.
But in November his Government hiked the value added tax, another form of indirect tax, from 11% to 15%, while also reactivating this tax to be applicable to the retail sector as well. Originally, the previous Mahinda Rajapaksa regime made VAT applicable to the retail sector. But, in a political move, he subsequently rescinded its application to the retail sector, only to be reactivated by the present government in November.
It was only last June (2016) that the Government signed an agreement with the IMF to increase its tax revenue, equivalent to 12.4% of GDP as per last year's estimates, to 15% of GDP by 2019. On that premise, the Government won a US$ 1.5 billion Extended Fund Facility from the IMF that June.
The increase in VAT and its re-applicability to the retail sector (supermarkets and such like), were steps taken to reach this 15% of GDP mandate.
Last week the Government passed a controversial new Inland Revenue Act where some of its provisions have as a focus on an increase indirect taxes either directly or indirectly.
Two such proposals are increasing company tax levied on the health sector from the present 12% to 28% and increasing the withholding tax (WHT) on interest income derived from instruments such as fixed deposits from the present 2.5% to 5%.
Usually, Sri Lanka's tax laws are effective from 1 April. But in those new developments, it's unsure whether the new taxes as per the new Act will be applicable from April of next year or as early as next month itself.
Nevertheless, more than doubling taxes on health sector company profits, i.e. 12% rate to 28% would naturally mean that the patients' bills would further go up. Companies in the healthcare sector are not going to take such increased costs lying down.
They will pass on such increased costs to the patient.
There is at present a ceiling on doctor's consultation fees with this figure fixed at Rs 2,000. There is also a price ceiling on certain drugs. To get over such roadblocks and mitigate any hits caused to those companies, bottom lines, those may lead to the importation of drugs which just pass the health regulator's minimum quality standards so as to keep the import prices of drugs purchased, in a sea of other increased costs, down.
But is the encouragement of the consumption of drugs which has a lower chance of patient recovery over the more expensive drugs which give the patient a better chance, the right way to formulate Government policy?
Those drugs, made more expensive because of higher taxes may be within the reach of only the rich. Increasing healthcare company taxation may help to uplift direct taxes, but at what cost?
Further, doubling WHT to 5% on fixed deposit interest income does not necessarily hit only the rich. Even the middle classes who live off such incomes suffer, thereby further increasing income inequalities. Government needs to rethink its tax policy.
Ministry Secretaries should be appointed on Best interest of Public not Minister Lethargy blocking change
- ‘A prisoner in Indian jail on Eelam soil’
- Sagala vows to crush Aava group Police deployed in full strength
- Politico’s son-in-law in school frock drama Teacher threatened after student is reprimanded
- Lanka alarmed over increased smuggling of ‘KG’
- SC to hear Tangalle ASP assault case
- 656 kg Glyphosate nabbed
- FPTP opens gate for undesirables, warns Amunugama
- EC to issue nomination notice on 27th
- NPC Education Minister shuns national flag Sarveshwaran was Chief Guest at school event
- Geological changes in Jaffna – Academics
- Violence against children World Vision launches campaign
- Females from soldier families on SLPP list
- JO goes to CIABOC against five COPE members
- Warrant issued on Jaliya Wickramasuriya For failure to appear in court
- Appuhamy admits to communicating with Aloysius Denies wrongdoing
- Gota’s objections thrown out Avant Garde case to go ahead
- JVP to team up with the devil! Vows to defeat LG polls gazette case
- UNP and JO in ‘secret deal’ to tarnish SLFP – Dayasiri
- CID evidence on COPE members and Aloysius JO urges Speaker to investigate
- An Inconsistent US Assertive China and Asia’s Hobbesian Order
- HNB clinch two titles
- Nadal wins defamation case
- One-legged footballer melts hearts
- Paine handed shock recall for Australia
- Italy's stars fall back to earth in Serie A
- 20th Army Para Athletic Meet 700 Servicemen and 5 Koreans in the fray 2 Korean Olympians provide international flavour
- 47 successful at AASL Technical Officers exam
- England’s May up to speed for Wallabies
- MCA Premier League 2018 MAS and DIMO into Semis
- 34th MBA Inter-Firm Team Badminton Championships 2017 McLarens Group are overall champions
- Asian Markets Rise As Risk Appetite Improves
- Singapore suspends trade ties with North Korea
- House Republicans pass $1.4Tn Tax Overhaul bill
- The world’s largest automaker is putting big money into electric vehicles in China
- Emotional toll of diabetes 'needs more recognition'
- Could buying paintings make you rich?
- Walmart helps to lift US markets
- $7.5 million Schumacher Ferrari sets record: Sotheby's
- Norway's state fund ‘needs to drop oil and gas investments'
- Japan railway 'deeply sorry' after train leaves 20 seconds early
- Remembering ‘Dictionary Johnson’
- Budgetary design of blue green enterprise
- A Time of Gifts Different Perspectives
- We were forced to work like animals
- Enjoying the bounty and giving thanks
- BREXIT Impact on free movement of people
- Padmavati triggers stir in Bollywood
- Military burning houses Rohingya refugees flee to Bangladesh
- Rice Revolution Role of Dairy Centres
- Pollution in India: 2.5 million people killed in 2015
- There is no journey with the UNP
- Core values of the UNP are eroding - Pradeep Jayewardene
- UN compensation for Kuwait workers Rs 3.2 B on migrant worker welfare
- Professor Matteo Legrenzi says: Gulf States are not keen on all-out war
- I regret the inconvenience caused to the public
- An argument for a new Constitution
- ‘Otriachchi’, ‘Orumiththa Nadu’, ‘Aekeeya Rajya’ and unitary state
- A Constitutional Framework for Sri Lanka
- THE STATE WITHIN A STATE SIVAGIRIYEN SiGIRIYATA
- A Creative Simulator -Anil Herath
- Are you ready for the big crunch party?– with Tharaka Eranda Caldera
- A Delhi Diwali
- The Unwrapped Hope - Translated
- PAST LIFE AND RULING PLANETS IN KRISHNAMURTHI PADHDHATHI
- Astrological remedies for Agriculture
- Unintentional Murder and law
- An Idyl in South India
- GRANDMA’S HAIR GROWTH OIL
- INTERPRETING ASIAN CINEMA: CHALLENGES AHEAD
- How Sanskrit journalism is slowly hogging headlines
- ice manufacturing in South Asia
- CMSC’s season finale concert
- Two documentaries on Sri Lanka in Film South Asia 2017
- Politics of nostalgia
- Kite Surfing Lanka Kalpitiya An experience of a lifetime
- Ella and mini Adam’s Peak
- A cave of history -Ravana Cave
- Man who rebelled against the British
- Rohingya kids fill void of parents
- Looking back at Sri Lanka Police