Russia-China Bonhomie: India Has No Reason To Worry
By Divya Kumar Soti
Chinese President Xi Jinping recently made an offer of alliance to Russia saying: "The world is on the verge of a radical change. We see how the European Union is gradually collapsing, as is the US economy — it is all over for the New World Order. So, it will never again be as it was before... in 10 years we will have a new world order in which the key will be the union of China and Russia."
Xi's 1 July 2016 statement on the 95th Anniversary of the founding of the Chinese Communist Party came within a few days of Russian President Vladimir Putin's visit to Beijing. And the fact that Xi decided to make this offer at the CPC meeting spoke volumes about his sincerity.
Xi was not just doing an exercise in futurology — he went further to articulate the possibility of a concrete military alliance between the two countries: "We are now seeing aggressive actions on the part of the United States, regarding both Russia and China. I believe that Russia and China could create an alliance towards which NATO will be powerless and which will put an end to the imperialist desires of the West."
While Russia did not immediately react to the Chinese proposal, President Putin — on the sidelines of the G-20 summit held in September at China's Hanzhou — supported China's rejection of the Hague Arbitration Court's Ruling on the South China Sea. Putin called it a "purely legal position".
In September itself, China and Russia held 8-day-long joint naval drills in the South China Sea which involved "island defence and offence exercises".
China and Russia have been holding such naval drills for a couple of years but this year, the exercises were shifted to South China Sea with Kremlin putting its diplomatic weight behind the Chinese stand against the Hague Arbitration Court's South China Sea ruling.
After the latest nuclear test by North Korea, South Korea has agreed to deploy the US Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD) anti-missile system angering China which sees the deployment as aimed at altering the strategic balance in the region.
Immediately after this announcement, China's State-run People's Daily warned that the US and South Korea will have to pay "a heavy price" for this deployment and promised a "counter-attack". The Americans had started feasibility studies for deployment of the THAAD system in South Korea in July and at that time the Russian Foreign Ministry had warned that the move will lead to "irreparable consequences".
Though North Korea's nuclear and missile tests may have been the immediate triggers, the deployment of THAAD on the Korean Peninsula, in the larger geo-strategic context, may be part of the US counter-strategy to the deployment of Russian Area Denial Weapon Systems focused on NATO forces in Europe and deployment of S-300 surface-to-air missile defence batteries in Iran.
The move is synergetic with the higher direction of US policy of shifting its military focus to the Asia-Pacific which is aimed at keeping China boxed in its maritime dilemma.
(Divya Kumar Soti is an independent defence analyst. Comments and suggestions on this article can be sent on: [email protected])
The recent release by Wikileaks of a private speech given by Democratic Presidential nominee Hillary Clinton in 2013, where she talked about the strategy of "ringing China with Missile Defense", specifies the long thought-out US strategy and tensions with Russia in East Europe and Middle East and exhorts Pentagon to implement these plans rather quickly. Recently, US Chief of Naval Operations, Admiral John Richardson, declared that the US won't shy away from naval deployments within the range of Russian and Chinese Area Denial Systems like an aircraft carrier killer missile.
While all this transpired in the Indian Ocean theatre, India inked the Logistics Exchange Memorandum of Agreement (LEMOA) with the United States which many reasonably argued will further degrade Indo-Russian relations and will exhort Russia to tilt towards China's protégé state in South Asia i.e. Pakistan. However, during President Putin's visit to India for the BRICS summit (at Goa on October 15-16, 2016), the Russians inked a crucial deal to sell the S-400 missile defence system to India at a time when Indo-Pak tensions are high after the Indian Army announced surgical strikes on terror launch pads in Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir (PoK).
This creates a very amazing situation. Now Russian air defence systems are deployed on the peripheries of East Europe and in Syria and Iran to keep US air power at bay while in India the S-400 system will keep Chinese air power at bay and will enable India to contemplate expanding punitive and pre-emptive moves against terror infrastructure based in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir, or PoK (what Pakistan calls Azad Kashmir) in exceptional threat scenarios. It is notable in this regard that Pakistan still enjoys Major Non-NATO US Ally (MNNA) status while China is building the China-Pak Economic Corridor (CPEC) through PoK.
China will have to factor in this boost to Indian military capabilities which may enable the Indian forces to hit deeper into Pakistan-based terror camps. This transfer will also help lessen concerns in India about chances of the Indian Air Force getting overstretched in a two-front war scenario. It is interesting to note that China is also deploying six battalions of the S-400 system and by transferring the same system to India, Russia has contributed to the conservation of the Sino-India strategic balance. Russia has also proposed to India the transfer of its latest multipurpose Shtorm super aircraft carrier design. This will understandably involve technology transfer to India.
This chain of events suggests that Russia-China cooperation in South Asia and the Indian Ocean Region at large is limited by geopolitical realities which put India in an envious and dominant position in the new Asian order. While trying to secure its western peripheries in Europe and increasing its footprint in the Middle East to seek access to the sea, Russia would not like to disengage from India, just because New Delhi has tilted towards the United States or to please the Chinese.
In the larger scheme of things, from the Russian point of view, cooperation with the Chinese has obvious limitations and is more useful for sustaining a balance of power in the South China Sea and Western Pacific Ocean — while disengaging from India, the pivotal state of the 21st century, by making a big issue out of US-India LEMOA, would erase the Russian strategic imprint on the southern peripheries of Asia and the Indian Ocean where the Chinese are still in no position to contribute much.
In the coming years, we may witness a scenario in which the US and Russia will compete to woo India and will end up strengthening its military capabilities to the disadvantage of rising Chinese power.
- Human Library held in Sammanthurai 4340
- SEUSL gets Faculty of Technology 4599
- Japan honours Speaker Jayasuriya 4366
- Public sector employment census on 17 Nov 4424
- Falls 73 cents in seven days ER down Rs 150.19 2nd lowest value ever 4329
- Clean drinking water project SL to get US$ 60 M from ADB 4336
- Attempt to smuggle elephant calf foiled 4366
- UK Minister for the UN and Commonwealth Baroness Anelay to visit Sri Lanka 4377
- New Police Division To protect victims and witnesses 4359
- Amending Muslim Marriage & Divorce Act Azwar condemns government’s decision 4428
- Bond scam a political project of UNP 4367
- Presidential Elections and US Nuclear Policy 4336
- Russia-China Bonhomie: India Has No Reason To Worry 4330
- Can oil markets survive an OPEC implosion? 4299
- Legendary Musician no more Funeral on 5 Nov 4498
- Bond scam probe President promises impartial judicial process 4270
- Ranil arrives in HK 4254
- Mahendran returns 4303
- Port City project Lanka clears environment concerns 4283
- Marriage & Divorce Laws Muslims protest against proposed changes 4816
- Saving children from accidents 3353
- OFFENCES RELATING TO DOCUMENTS: FORGERY 3399
- The Blair Years Part Three Privatization’s disastrous route 6694
- Police Rugby has made an Indelible Mark 3608
- Cops target top four finish 3288
- SLT e Sports championship Phase 2 in Kandy 3289
- Visakha- Ladies Annual Water Polo Visakha in 6th consecutive win 3287
- Lanka Plate Snooker in Kandy today 3289
- De Mazenod. St. Benedict’s and Isipathana on first inning POINTS 3300
- Windies end Test win drought 3287
- TILAK ABEYSINGHE NO MORE 3491
- 47th Sir John Tarbet Championship Ladies Makes History 3299
- Imesh hat-trick in Peterite victory 3249
- ‘Singer Cup’ U-19 Cricket Dimuth makes second ton 3259
- Sailors, Cops clash in opener 3269
- AFC Cup Football Tournament Laos edges-out Sri Lanka 2-1 3224
- Namal to coach CH 3274
- Triangular American Football League 2016 Colombo Lions take on Peshawar WolfPak 3324
- Criminality within societies 3858
- T-Bill, T-Bond market outflow, tip of the iceberg Rupee and interest rates in peril 7092
- CB bonds controversy reaches fever pitch 5542
- Dealing with Corruption Systemic Change not political victimizations – Prof Rajiva Wijesinha 8878
- Entire Police force is not to blame for this tragedy An unfortunate isolated incident 10854
- ‘Footnote group’ belittled AG 10239
- BASEL III FROM JANUARY-CBSL 3890
- Cabinet nods migrant worker pension scheme 2980
- We expect special treatment Rishad tells WTO in Geneva 2931
- ETCA a must given current situ – W.A. Wijewardena 2964
- Carson Cumberbatch’s Equity One delisted 2996
- Shares gain for second day 2971
- Japanese SMEs eye SL for India access 2961
- Alliance Finance wins CMO Asia award 2954
- Egypt floats currency Currency value quickly reduces by almost 50% against dollar 2949
- Sri Lankan students to China with Huawei 3044
- Commercial Leasing opens branch in Borella 3036
- Emerging Media wins Flame Award 2969
- RV Fashion wins award at FLAME 2016 3036
- BoC’s Green Banking goes with digitization 3214
- Commercial Bank offers exciting revamped website 3134
- Cigarettes Relation between price and consumption 7211
- Safeguarding its citizens 8369
- MISCHIEF AND ILLEGAL REMOVAL OF WRECKS 9368
The Flash returns 2978