Auto industry’s Trump fear
"I like the car I'm in now. It's a Chevrolet Suburban. Made in the USA," Donald Trump told the Detroit News last year when the then presidential hopeful was asked to name his favourite car from his 100-plus vehicle fleet that includes a scissor-door Lamborghini Diablo and a 1956 Rolls-Royce Silver Cloud.
For General Motors, Chevy's owner, it was nice PR, the latest in a series of endorsements from the Trumps that reach back like a stretch limo to the Cadillac Trump's landlord father Fred used to pick up his rent checks. In the 1980s Donald Trump even worked on building a Trump-branded Cadillac, complete with VCR and paper shredder. The Trumps may be fans of the US's largest car manufacturer but GM, and the car industry in general, should have been paying more attention to the final sentence of his pre-election endorsement: "Made in the USA."
Trump hit out at the car industry last week like a drive-by shooter, firing off a series of angry tweets about their outsourcing of US jobs. Those tweets will be the hottest topic this week as Detroit's annual car jamboree, the North American International Auto Show, gets started. It's a chance for the industry to show off all its latest products and for its executives to address the media about the future. Trump's blimp-like shadow is overhanging the event as executives and analysts fret about how this overtly interventionist president will use the bully pulpit of his office, and his Twitter account, to try and force a radical change in the way they do business.
"Pretty much everybody is dreading being the subject of a tweet. Getting hauled out into the court of public opinion with virtually no warning is not something anybody wants to get engaged with," said Kristin Dziczek, director of the industry, labour and economics group at the Michigan-based Center for Automotive Research (CAR).
The auto industry matters to the US and to Trump. Six years after a recession that almost destroyed it, the US car industry has made a miraculous recovery. Last week it reported record sales for 2016. Auto manufacturers, suppliers and dealers employ over 1.5 million people and directly contribute to the creation of another 5.7m jobs, according to the CAR.
Trump won thanks in large part to States where the auto industry is strongest. The Republican candidate took Michigan, home to the auto show and still the industry's hub, from the Democrats for the first time since 1988 with a campaign that tore into companies that have sent those voters' jobs abroad, especially to Mexico. Ford bore the brunt of Trump's attacks during the election. Last week it was GM's turn. Then Toyota's.
"General Motors is sending Mexican-made model of Chevy Cruze to US car dealers-tax free across border. Make in USA or pay big border tax!" the president elect warned via his favorite megaphone, Twitter.
Two days later, he was after Toyota. "Toyota Motor said will build a new plant in Baja, Mexico, to build Corolla cars for US. NO WAY! Build plant in US or pay big border tax," he tweeted. Toyota's plans were old news but the tweet came on the same day that its president, Akio Toyoda, had told reporters he was keen to work with the president-elect.
These were the latest in a series of attacks on major US employers, including Carrier, Boeing and Lockheed Martin, that have so far brought CEOs running, cap in hand, to Trump Tower to make up for their alleged corporate misdeeds. Shortly after the GM tweet, Ford announced it had canned plans to open a $1.6bn plant in Mexico and would add new jobs building electric and hybrid vehicles at a plant in Flat Rock, Michigan. Trump hailed the move: "Thank you to Ford for scrapping a new plant in Mexico and creating 700 new jobs in the US. This is just the beginning – much more to follow," he tweeted.
Matt DeLorenzo, managing editor for Kelley Blue Book, said Trump was "playing to his base and a lot of the voters who put him in office were industrial midwest, blue collar, union workers. All his tweets and pronouncements have been geared to addressing that audience,"
Ford had already warned that the car industry was expecting a slowdown in sales, especially of smaller vehicles like the ones that would have been built in Mexico. So scrapping the plan makes economic as well as political sense for the company, but market watchers doubt the industry and Trump's agendas will remain compatible.
GM is expected to start laying off more than 3,000 factory workers in Michigan and Ohio, another state that voted for Trump, starting later this month. Will they defend that decision if Trump goes on the attack?
The car industry is truly international and China is its largest market. GM and its joint venture partners sold 3.87m vehicles in China in 2016, up 7.1% from the previous year. China accounts for a third of GM's sales. Like its corporate peers, GM has – so far – remained silent over Trump's anti-China rhetoric, but a trade war would be a disaster for the company.
Some wonder if Trump will really translate tough talk into policy. "There is always a difference between campaigning and governing and we have not yet seen what governing looks like," said Dziczek. Others are more concerned. Trump is in a honeymoon period because "there is nobody speaking out", said Daniel Ikenson, director of the Herbert A Stiefel Center for Trade Policy Studies at the Cato Institute. Republicans have remained silent as he has attacked businesses they once defended and the business community has even gone out of its way to endorse Trump cabinet picks that have overt protectionist views, he said.
The incoming president has clearly signalled that Obama's trade-friendly, internationalist era is over, said Ikenson. The US steel industry lawyer Robert Lighthizer is Trump's choice for United States trade representative, the anti-China economist Peter Navarro is set to head the newly created National Trade Council at the White House and the billionaire investor Wilbur Ross, a staunch critic of the US's existing trade agreements, is Trump's pick to lead the commerce department.
"These are people who if you mentioned them a few months ago, businesspeople would shudder. Now: 'Hey, great idea, we like the enforcement mentality.' They are scared. To me, this is extremely disconcerting and dangerous. This silence of people who should be speaking out is reminiscent of the 1930s. The stakes might be different but the it's a similar sort of thing," Ikenson said.
So far, corporate reaction to Trump's election has been bland; business leaders like that he's is "pro-growth" and wants to cut red tape. But that may change once Trump is in office. The president may also find that changing the industry is harder than he thinks.
The auto industry is a global supplier with a global supply chain. While it's politically easy to target US neighbours like Mexico for "taking American jobs", the real picture is more nuanced than anything you could fit into a 140-character tweet.
Forty per cent of the parts that make up the average vehicle imported to the US from Mexico were made in the US. "We are sending them parts, engines, transmissions that then come back to us as vehicles that have been assembled," said Dziczek.
Imposing duties on foreign imports makes about as much sense as "building a concrete wall in the middle of what used to be Ford's Dearborn plant", said Ikenson. "The factory floor spans borders and oceans now. Imposing tariffs like this is like separating the chassis line from the engine line."
CAR is predicting Mexican auto assembly capacity will more than double in size between 2010 and 2020, thanks in part to lower labour costs but also to Mexico's free trade agreements with 40 countries that give it access to 47% of the world's automotive market. In the next five years, CAR predicts, most Mexican car exports will go to countries outside the North American Free Trade Agreement (Nafta), which Trump has attacked for taking US jobs. Dziczek doubts one man, even the US president, can hold back those forces. "You put a plant in place for 30 or 40 years. You don't worry about four to eight years. Plants last a lot longer than presidents," she said.
As Trump prepares to take office, Ikenson said he worried that autoworkers and other voters who backed Trump in part as a protest against the impact of decades of free trade may not like what they get. If trade agreements are scrapped and imports imposed on foreign goods, "they will be the first wave of casualties. We went from 19m workers in manufacturing in 1979 to about 12m today. That goes down to 10m workers," he predicted.
But Trump and Trump's voters have heard this argument before and they aren't buying it. On the crowded floor of Detroit's Cobo Center this week, and in the suites and conference rooms of its hotels, the car industry's biggest brains will all be working overtime trying to figure out how to deal with the man their workers elected.
- Desk thumping greets Jayaratne crossover 3696
- Vasu challenges Rajitha 3693
- Sensational dig in Wilpattu 3696
- Indian HC presents credentials 3691
- Don’t attend Nugegoda rally 3695
- Coach assaults 14-year-old 3690
- Govt seeks Rs 26.9 M for ECT 3693
- JVP urges Parliament probe 3690
- 50% Lankan docs employed abroad 3691
- Pillaiyan ordered killing – AG 3693
- Won’t rest until ‘Govt sent home’ – Wimal 3693
- UFO sightings unlikely – expert 3693
- Brexit requires Parliament Nod – UK Supreme Court 3690
- Govt to Seize Perpetual Treasuries’ Funds 3700
- Soldiers turn tables on CR 3694
- Why The Black Sea? 3693
- Student turns out trishaw ambulance 3694
- Budu Medura opened at SEUSL 3692
- Lankans amongst top Swiss asylum requests in 2016 3693
- CLARIFICATION 3687
- Canine and feline companions 3018
- Nixon’s Heir 3017
- Radical paradigm shift in Trump foreign policy 3026
- Sumo National Championship today 2814
- Sri Lanka U-19’s 303/6 2816
- De Villiers back as captain 2816
- Helitha Vithanage scores second ton 2815
- Lasith Fernando scores century 2814
- UPUL THARANGA TO CAPTAIN ODI team 2817
- SL in series decider 2816
- Venus ‘living the dream’ as hot Coco awaits 2809
- Federer blitzes Zverev to set up Wawrinka semi 2810
- Italian junior in tears after controversial DQ 2809
- Prince of Wales Joint Champions 2809
- Smartphones are ruining sports skills and awareness 2810
- Hot shot Warner happy to rest for tough India test 2809
- Citizens Dev. Business champions 2809
- Matches postponed until 11 February 2809
- Bogus claims of foreign investments! 3432
- Docs threaten TU action if... 3440
- Coal industry mafia sacked me 3666
- BT European chief to resign over Italian scandal 3038
- Boosting FDI a must for wealth creation 3037
- Education Sector has created a surplus of engineers 3038
- Aus and NZ moot ‘TPP 12 minus one’ 3038
- Money printing 6 times greater than liquidity 3038
- Acclaimed scientist urges SL to retire coal plants 3039
- Mahendran not working here 3034
- A350 penalty only Rs 14.7B 3035
- Asian markets mixed as Trump acts 3035
- Habitat for Humanity breaks ground in Aranayake 3034
- CIM Sri Lanka to hold first Talking Point Programme for this year 3030
- Micromax launches two power-packed phones 3030
- Singer Sri Lanka tops in LMD 100 3031
- SLID poses the question on Women in the Boardroom, ‘Are men ready for it?’ 3030
- Sri Lanka at Spanish International Tourism Trade Fair 3030
- Way for True Conciliation! 3918
- Mathews is confident of bouncing back 2698
- Djokovic still the biggest rival, says Murray 3289
- Odissi dance recital Taal Taranga 4592
- Candid and Undeterred remarks on Luke Wright 4660
- Enchanting scrutiny into historical novels 4612
- Davena Vihagun (aka Burning Birds) for The Ingamar Bergman Film Award 4627
- Rev. Fr. Harold Panditharatne – Teacher Par Excellance 4608
- Postnational cinema? 4756
- Authentic poetry rewarded 2582
- Kala Pola 2017 2567
- A mighty platform for the creative writer 2568
- The start of a new year 2571
- Special Chinese New Year food festival 2571
- Escape to Sigiriya 2575
- Weightlifting Fairy Kim Bok-joo 2795
- A clash over hybrid blood and power 2801
- The augmented reality game experience 2794
- Classrooms of the future 2796
- Aiming for the diehard fans 2797
- Sri Lanka enters endurance racing 2792