Why wages have lagged behind global jobs recovery
In a world of sluggish economic growth, two conflicting trends puzzle policy makers: Why are companies hiring so aggressively and why haven't wages until lately risen more rapidly?
From Tokyo to London, jobless rates have kept falling even as labour market indicators suggest economies are nearing full employment. The US unemployment rate edged up to 4.7% in December as more workers entered the labour force, but remains close to a nine-year low of 4.6%. In Japan, at 3.1%, it's around its lowest level since the early 1990s. The UK jobless rate was 4.8% in the three months to October, close to a four-decade low, despite the country's historic vote to leave the European Union last June. Even in the 19-nation eurozone, the unemployment rate has hit a seven-year low of 9.8%.
It's common for firms to hire large numbers of workers early in an economic recovery, to deal with backlogs of orders. That tends to slow productivity growth. But companies have been adding workers for much longer than expected, economists say, and productivity has remained subdued for an extended period as firms eschewed capital investments.
"It's very hard to rationalize why businesses are adding so many workers...throughout advanced economies at a time when growth [has been] near zero or even declining," said Adam Posen, president of the Peterson Institute for International Economics in Washington. "It's very cheap to substitute capital for labor, in part because of what central banks are doing." Low interest rates make it cheap to invest in labour-substituting equipment.
Policy makers, particularly in Europe, have been taken by surprise. The Bank of England said in mid-2013 it would consider raising interest rates when unemployment fell to 7%, but had to backtrack after hitting that level in six months. The European Central Bank says it was caught out in recent years by a stronger than expected rebound in employment relative to economic growth.
Normally, economists expect wages to rise as the unemployment rate falls, and as inflation and productivity increase. But those relationships appear to have broken down: Wage growth in the US and Japan since 2007 has been as much as 1 percentage point per year less than standard economic models would suggest, said Oxford Economics, a consultancy firm.
Wage growth only recently appears to have picked up in the US Average hourly earnings rose 2.9% in December from a year earlier, greater than the 2% average that prevailed during much of the expansion. Still, it's too early to say if that will be sustained and other US wage measures are less robust.
Wages in 22 advanced economies grew by an average 3.7% a year between 1995 and 2007, but by less than 2% a year between 2008 and 2016, Oxford Economics calculates.
The Phillips curve, which reflects an inverse relationship between wages and unemployment, appears to have stopped working in many places.
Economists suggest a range of possible explanations.
First, the types of jobs created since the crisis aren't the same as those lost beforehand. While jobs were lost primarily in the construction and manufacturing sectors, they have been added in the services sector, says Stefano Scarpetta, an economist with the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, a think tank for advanced economies. In the euro area, nearly all of the 3.2 million positions created since the recovery were service-sector jobs, primarily in trade, transport and business services, according to the ECB. Many of these positions tend to be harder to substitute with machines, and don't pay so well.
Second, workers' bargaining power may have been eroded due to general economic uncertainty, labour-market reforms and intensifying global competition from China and elsewhere. Workers in new service-sector jobs may not be organized into unions, reducing the pressure for wage hikes, said Christopher A. Pissarides, a Nobel Prize-winning economist at the London School of Economics. Employees have also been changing jobs less frequently, which is associated with weaker wage growth.
Third, some firms may not have been able to reduce labour costs as much as they wanted after the crisis, and therefore dragged the adjustment out over time. ECB officials pointed to such "pent-up wage restraint" at their October meeting, according to the minutes. Public-sector pay has also been squeezed as governments tightened their belts, pulling down average wages and perhaps weighing on private-sector pay by proxy.
Fourth, the changing makeup of the labour force may have artificially supported wages after the recession, but subsequently held them down. Since low-wage workers were disproportionately fired, and firms slowed new hires –who typically earn less – average wages held up, according to researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. As the economy has strengthened, lower-wage workers have been re-entering the workforce. Meanwhile, highly-paid baby boomers have started to retire, putting downward pressure on wages.
All that means wage growth may be a poor indicator of job-market strength. A better measure, the Fed researchers argue, is the pay of workers continuously in full-time work, ignoring those entering and leaving the labor force. That indicator, which is tracked by the Atlanta Fed, suggests wage growth has been about 1 percentage point per year higher since 2014 than is indicated by average hourly earnings.
Some economists expect wages to rise more strongly as labor markets tighten further and postcrisis ripples dissipate. The latest US report on wages suggests that's the case. But with productivity growth still weak, a wage boom at this stage of the expansion doesn't look to be in the offing.
- NUJ 109th Birth anniversary 3369
- Mangala to urge 24-month extension 3541
- Namal slaps CBK with defamation 3444
- Pakistan still eyeing JF-17 Thunder Fighter sale to Sri Lanka 3151
- CID grills govt Printer, Director, others 3232
- LRC seeks Police protection 3141
- MR to meet Tamil and Muslim leaders 3212
- Leprosy hits western province 3150
- skipper of ill-fated boat remanded 3136
- Raggers will be promptly expelled 3164
- Double-speak from SB on Wimal 3167
- VX nerve agent killed Kim Jong-nam 3141
- More snags foul up Constitution making 3291
- NFPWHR warns of massive protest 3143
- Mangala meets US HDP delegation 3146
- SL Police deny ‘hunting’ refugees in HK 3135
- 1500 students denied Uni education 3219
- SLFP CMs to boycott meeting 3134
- Wimal not a party leader – Dayasiri 3141
- New Zealand-bound boat people held 3128
- February – a celebratory month 3116
- Political mayhem 3134
- Significance of Sri Lanka’s legal profession 3121
- Now or never for Havies 2249
- Bad light saves day for Isipathana 2245
- Golfer Arumugam no more 2246
- Royal resist late Joes’ onslaught 2251
- Sadeera's 177 n.o. guides SL 'A' 2242
- Sadeera pushes for Test spot 2521
- Wesley players face disciplinary action 2248
- De Villiers' record sets up thumping win 2235
- Australians humble India 2235
- Dilini edges Sadeepa in long jump 2239
- Ronaldinho launches soccer academy in China 2216
- French possess fear factor, says Zebo 2220
- UB Finance main sponsor for STC Rugby for 2017 2216
- New circular issued to allow player poaching 2322
- Malinda claims seven scalps 2218
- SAITM students will not be accepted by any country– Prof. Hiran Amerasekera 3164
- I have no issues with the Minister– Anoma Gamage 3510
- LG elections should be under new system 3335
- Google's self-driving firm sues Uber 2507
- Colombo Fashion Week dates for Summer season, 13 – 18 March 2513
- International Thunder Cat Power Boat Racing in Bentota- a thrilling experience 2508
- BPPL Holdings Limited announces Rs. 368 Mn IPO 2509
- Durdans Lab Service adds ‘Predictive Tests’ for disease prevention 2510
- INSEE Cement wins Green Platinum Award at HarithaSihinaya 2017 2509
- CIC to elevate education in rural Agri-Communities 2510
- NTB rewards 50 lucky American Express Cardmembers with latest iPhone 7 2509
- HNB offers new benefit package through agreement with Indra Traders 2521
- Crescent Global sponsors Insurance Awards 2508
- Hameedia’s Bespoke Tailoring offer 2501
- NDB relocates Wennappuwa branch 2501
- Foreign exits top Rs 120.6B 2502
- Brandix gifts stationery and school bags to 5,700 children 2499
- AIC Campus European State University Foundation after O/Levels 2501
- Valencia stun Real Madrid 2731
- GSP+ To sustain economy or to Mutate society? 3048
- Fully fledged Media Commission by June – DGI 3079
- A musical evening-Hindi film songs 3035
- Sitar recital 3031
- Alston Koch to sing at the ‘OSCARS’ after party 3037
- Luang Prabang – A Journey into Sublimity 3033
- Blue all the way 3033
- Footpaths Towards Deconstruction - Part 10 3035
- Employees rewarded 1327
- Training in excellence 1326
- Human – elephant conflict rears up again 1369
- Nature in its wild pristine beauty 1332
- A touch of Yalpanam 1332
- Blood facts 1328
- SS501 1671
- An immersive and inclusive learning experiences 1674
- Emerging future trailblazers 1672
- An educational celebration 1670
- A campaign to target8.4 million Lankans 1673
- An epic battle 1671