Western encouragement of terrorism
Another mark of increasing age, though I suppose I should be pleased at this one, was a request to deliver a memorial lecture. The topic given to me was "The March of Folly", which led me to look up the origin of the phrase. I knew it was the title of a book by the popular American historian Barbara Tuchman, but I had thought this was the one she wrote about the beginnings of the First World War, chronicling the headlong rush into a war that could have been avoided, and which destroyed the world its perpetrators thought to perpetuate.
In fact "The March of Folly" is a later book, based on the idea that folly is the pursuit by governments of policies contrary to their own interests. Tuchman deals with four examples of this, beginning with the decision of the Trojans to take into their city the horse left on the beach by the Greeks who had pretended to abandon their attempt to conquer Troy. She goes on to discuss the policies of the Popes who precipitated the Reformation, and then the British blunders that led to the independence of the United States. Finally, and at length, she deals with the American disaster in Vietnam.
All very interesting subjects and I should now read the book. But it gave me a focus for this new series, which will look at recent political history in the context of folly in the Tuchman sense. I will not confine myself to governments alone, since the whole picture demands looking also at what others in the political arena engage in. And the series will be different from the lecture, which will have to be tightly focused. But these articles will I hope provide some food for thought, and with luck some changes in approach – assuming, that is, that those who decide, and those who influence decision making, both read and think.
Folly of the West
I will begin however, in an area where obviously I cannot hope for influence, since I shall talk about the folly of the West in persecuting us for achieving what it pretends it desires namely the eradication of terrorism. But from the Sri Lankan perspective it is essential to consider this too, for the mess the current government is in, springs largely from its unthinking acceptance of Western mythology. Some in the government, and even perhaps the Prime Minister, have begun to realize how badly they blundered way back in 2015, but he has no idea how to reverse gear effectively, and he certainly cannot even begin to do this while Mangala Samaraweera continues to run foreign affairs and bleat helplessly in Geneva.
We need to begin with the sheer cynicism with which the West treated us in 2009. In the preceding eight years, under George Bush, the United States had been relatively positive about us, and certainly its Ambassador Bob Blake was more balanced than the spivvy British High Commissioner Dominic Chilcott, or the ineffably patronizing, also British, European Union Head of Mission, Julian Wilson.
But in 2009, Bob changed, and explained to one of my staff that he now served a different government. Sadly foreign policy running was made there by Hillary Clinton whom Barack Obama had made his Secretary of State. This was disastrous for Sri Lanka, which had been relieved when she failed to get the Democrat nomination, given that we knew that the terrorist diaspora were congratulating themselves, on having won favour with her after massive contributions to her campaign.
So she did her worst, aided and abetted by sanctimonious hypocrites like Susan Rice and Samantha Power, and the dominatrix they sent to Geneva, Eileen Donahoe. These bleeding hearts, as a leading official in the Bush Administration called them, were powerless to change factors such as Guantanamo which they had bewailed under Bush, so they turned their fire on easy targets like Sri Lanka (indeed he told me that if we just did a few things to keep them happy, they could then be diverted to an even easier target such as Djibouti).
Why were they doing this? First of course, was the commitments Hillary Clinton had, according to the Diaspora, made to them. Second was their attempt to show genuine proponents of human rights that they were doing something. Through their rhetoric about Sri Lanka, aided and abetted by less obviously manipulative government funded entities such as Human Rights Watch, they could divert attention from their misdeeds in places such as Libya and Syria, and their support for fundamentalist terrorists in those places. Third was the feeling that Sri Lanka under Mahinda Rajapaksa was not prepared to become a cog in a US machine, yet another willing agent of the domination they wished to perpetuate.
I could understand then Mahinda's point when I told him that a few simple measures would relieve the pressure. He told me that, whatever he did, they would hate him. Given how badly the West had behaved in Geneva, the Americans included from 2009 on, he was correct. But where he failed was in keeping India on board. Indeed, he was manipulated by his principle adviser on foreign affairs at the time – not G.L. Peiris, who was also an easily manipulated cipher – into thinking that India was the real enemy, not the West, after India sadly supported the West's resolution of March 2012.
But that is another story. To return to what the West was up to, the sad part, the folly is that their strategy was entirely counterproductive. Whereas, given that Sri Lankans in positions of influence find their comfort zone in the West, given that the West is our most important market, Sri Lanka, if treated well, would have been a helpful ally. But this would not have entailed unthinking adherence to a Western agenda, for we would not have been hostile to others under Western duress. And this was perhaps the sticking point, for foolishly the West wants total subservience, not simply support for its own vital interests.
Total domination is what – leaving aside in the oddly included Trojan Horse episode – the protagonists in Barbara Tuchman's book wanted. But what authoritarians down the ages have failed to recognize is that, when such efforts at domination fail, the reaction is total rejection, not the general camaraderie with everyone that is the preferred, and most profitable, path for the comparatively weak.
Another fiasco as far as the rationale for Western hypocrisy went was the brilliance with which the Diaspora dumped their patrons when they failed. After putting all their eggs in the Clinton basket in 2008, they were fortunate that Obama, in his desire for wider acceptance, gave her so much authority (which we later gathered had contributed to the fiasco in Libya, where he had not initially supported the overthrow of Gaddafi). In 2016, Clinton lost and it was the Trump the Diaspora had striven to defeat who won, with no hope of the return of the harridan. But almost immediately they abandoned the fallen woman and set up Tamils for Trump, which will doubtless soon convince him that they were heart and soul behind him from the start.
This certainly happened in Britain. The terrorist Diaspora worked incredibly hard for the Labour Party, and indeed David Milliband, as Foreign Secretary, explained to the Americans who were not as bitter about Sri Lanka initially that this was for electoral considerations. But when in 2010 Labour lost, Tamils emerged as strong supporters of David Cameron (with Sri Lanka incidentally having contributed to this easy transition by having failed to appoint a new High Commissioner for months, so that the opportunity to establish good relations with the new government was squandered).
Decimation of civilians
But where I think the West shot itself most seriously in the foot was in losing the chance to understand how to deal effectively with terrorism without decimation of the civilians amidst whom terrorists operate. Any objective examination of what we did makes it clear that we took care of civilians as best possible within the context of the Tigers using them as human shields. We provided health and education facilities throughout, including transporting to hospitals in government territory those in need of medical help (all it would seem, given that we took along even more who were described by the ICRC as bystanders).
Essential food was available, as is obvious from the stocks of grain that the Tigers used to build barricades. And the hundreds of thousands who fled to government territory when we created an opportunity for this, in April 2009, when the Tigers were trying to sacrifice everyone, make it clear that the civilians had not gone willingly as was claimed. Indeed the failure of aid agencies to persuade the Tigers to allow their workers to leave with them makes clear the intransigence of the Tigers as well as the hypocrisy of those agencies that did nothing about the thousands of ordinary people the Tigers were forcibly keeping.
But perhaps I am naïve in thinking the West actually cares about civilians. Certainly the number of civilians who have suffered in the wars they have been relentlessly waging in the Middle East, the flippancy with which they admit that drones have destroyed the innocent, their continuing protection of the wicked who support them, suggest that they do not care a hoot for the values they use to undermine countries they do not like.
And yet, that too is counterproductive. As they found with so many tyrants they supported who then switched over, it is only alliances based on principles that can be relied on. And even when they can be sure that there will be no abandoning of the West, as with Israel or the fascist regime they have now installed in the Ukraine, the price they have to pay in continuing support for increasingly vicious behaviour rises all the time. Any except the most bigoted must realize that, with every excess the United States permits Israel, disenchantment with the West increases, and this will soon change even the stance of what are seen as devoted allies – whose excesses, it should be noted, the West continues to endorse.
But, Barbara Tuchman noted, the march of folly will continue until disaster occurs. The worry now though is that that disaster will engulf others too, and those who have in no way contributed to the mess will also suffer. It will be no consolation that the perpetrators of the disaster will suffer what for them will be a minor setback.
- PEB to manage SOEs - Kabir 3422
- The other side of the story 3432
- First Ambassador of SL accredited to Principality of Andorra 3411
- Entrance test in Colombo on 21 May 3419
- A fair and expeditious solution 3419
- Anti-imperialist coalition now steadier than ever 3421
- Dramatic comeback for Europe 3433
- Turkish Thorn in EU’s side 3417
- Judges probing Bond scam threatened 3434
- Only 63.2% utilized – Ranil 3429
- UK officially exits from EU 3413
- Weerawansa admitted to Nat. Hospital 3414
- Monkey robs British student’s phone 3430
- Around 800,000 suffer from depression 3412
- Will meet when time is right 3416
- Freedom fighter or terrorist? 3208
- Fond memories 3189
- In pursuit of A dream 3186
- The farce and folly of the UNHRC 3244
- The deluge we caused in Geneva 3481
- Tragedy of the common class 3141
- I’ve got my day job back- Sharapova 2856
- CPCA conducts coaching programme 2844
- RTC ALL SET FOR A GALLOPING APRIL SEASON 2842
- Sinhawansa new General Secretary 2846
- Event successfully conducted on 18/19 March 2838
- Brazil book World Cup berth 2841
- Top-seed Wawrinka ousted 2837
- Aussie media slam 'classless' Kohli 2838
- Former England keeper Read to retire 2832
- South Africa 'saved by rain' 2831
- India’s Yogi Chief Minister 2533
- The roles people play Prioritizing Sex & Gender 3262
- Typical double standards & hypocrisy 3112
- Main cause of kidney diseases 3122
- ‘Posh Pooches’ to be lavished with love 3058
- Preventive measures 3035
- Opening a can of worms 3096
- COMPOUNDED MISERY 3591
- Forefathers of Tamils of SL were original inhabitants of this Country 3856
- Jaffna Prepares for Chronic Kidney Disease 3447
- North wanted to send 1,000 participants – Shantha Bandara 3085
- India should leave SL alone– Dr. Sudarshini Fernandopulle 3707
- International mechanism will try LTTE cadres again – Thulasi 3371
- Rewarded for sensitizing rights of the disabled 3256
- Foreign Judges can hear cases – Niran Anketell 3196
- We await President’s response – Gemunu 3252
- Jade Restaurants brings unbeatable seasonal offers 2609
- SRI LANKA’S FIRST TAXI METER WITH PRINTER INTRODUCED 2709
- Munchee treat for Sri Pada pilgrims 2606
- LAND ROVER DISCOVERY WITH DRONE TO HELP RED CROSS 2613
- Why Brexit is best for Britain 2612
- ‘BOC Triple Wasi’ produces 125 lucky winners 2612
- Avurudu discounts from retailers for 2620
- High rates and gifts for Avurudu from Pan Asia 2618
- DFCC Bank’s ‘Avurudu Hat-Trick’ offers season’s best rewards 2619
- Cinnamon TBCasia sets benchmark at ITB Berlin 2611
- Softlogic opens Burger King and Softlogic Max in Ja-Ela 2612
- Keells Super partners Institute of Post Harvest Technology 2619
- Singer Mega launches ‘Singer Mega Millionaire’ promotion 2613
- Global Housing & Real Estate commences Marriott project 2616
- London Stock Exchange-Deutsche Boerse deal blocked by EU 2619
- Domestic succumbs to burn injuries 2543
- The crisis in Parliament: Twilight of a functioning democracy 3524
- Mispriced Risk of Infectious Diseases 2459
- Musicalisation of Narrative 5193
- The Many Faces of Galle -Part 2 5232
- Footpaths Towards Deconstruction- Part 14 5202
- Afternoon Shadows 5209
- Living up to ideals 5379
- Clash of the Titans in Nuwara Eliya 5254
- Musicalized Version of Nostalgia 5476
- The Many Faces of Galle 6343
- The plight of our corals 1756
- India’s largest international décor mall launched in Bangalore 1735
- The games gods and politicians play 1726
- A challenged life 1721
- The Threshold: Patching up our privileged defeats 1791
- Animal assisted therapy 1719
- Empowering vocational studies 1835
- Your dream gaming machine 1843
- An enchanting remake 1841
- Refreshingly delicious 1836
- Xiumin 1845
- Batteries to firebombs 1354
Weather today 765