Sri Lanka: Has There Been Genuine National Reconciliation?
By Dr. Archana Arul
If there is considerable consternation in political circles in India over what took place at the UN Human Rights Commission in Geneva recently over a two-year extension for Sri Lanka to come to terms with issues of the post-conflict era, it is only understandable.
Once again the international community, led by the United States and Britain, has given one more chance to the powers that be in Colombo to put in motion a judicial and political process that squarely comes to terms with the national reconciliation process.
That there has been constant huffing and puffing on how to go about the procedural aspects of substantive issues in the island nation has been conveniently glossed over – for now, there is another extension and in the name of a Consensus Resolution on which there was no vote.
In the event of a division, member-nations would have been forced to spell out their views leading to embarrassing moments in the fashion they were going to characterize their versions of the goings on in Sri Lanka.
Colombo got the two-year extension to fully implement the commitments made under the 2015 Resolution but not before the top Human Rights official Zeid Ra'ad al-Hussein made it known that Sri Lanka had registered only 'slow progress' of reforms.
Consistently, since the end of the ethnic conflict in 2009, the governments in Sri Lanka have been accused of war crimes especially during the final weeks of the war. The issue is not only the alleged killing of Tamil civilians but also of those families who have been demanding a closure on those who have disappeared during the course of the 26-year-long brutal war.
The regime of President Mahinda Rajapaksa scoffed at a United Nations probe into the alleged crimes of the Sri Lankan Army and the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam and even going to the extent of denying entry of United Nations officials into the country.
The coming of President Maithiripala Sirisena signalled a positive change in Colombo's attitude, but two years down the line there is a perception that the new scheme of things have not come to terms with war crimes, torture, unlawful killings and forced disappearances. And adding to all this is the persistent objection to formal internationalization of any probe on war crimes.
Statistics vary but it is generally believed that more than 100,000 persons – mostly Tamil civilians – perished during the conflict and perhaps an equal number that have not been accounted for. Even at the recent Geneva meeting, Sri Lanka's Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs Harsha de Silva maintained that his government was striving to establish law of the land and end impunity under "Sri Lankan-government-led processes".
But Human Rights Watch echoed the views expressed by the Rights High Commissioner, especially in the rather slow implementation of the Council's Resolution 30/1.
"The promised office on enforced disappearances has yet to be established, although enabling legislation was passed in June 2016.
Legislation to establish three other transitional justice mechanisms pledged under the 30/1 resolution remain in draft form. We are also concerned about other undertakings in the resolution that have not been implemented" HRW said in a statement a few days before the latest Geneva session.
Even more telling was the observation on security sector reforms. "...barring a handful of prosecutions in high profile cases, it has simply not occurred. Torture by the security forces, remains endemic, a fact underscored by the recent report of the Special Rapporteur on torture as well as by Human Rights Watch and other groups."
The government talks about a 'zero tolerance' policy against torture while in Geneva, 'but takes no action back home', the HRW said, a view that is endorsed by independent observers and Tamil Groups, including the Sri Lankan Tamil Diaspora.
To a very large extent, all these have been brushed aside by official Colombo in the past, especially by the Rajapaksa regime, as having vested interests or pro-LTTE leaning sympathizers.
"Sri Lanka took a strong step in co-sponsoring resolution 30/1, raising hopes and the promise of reconciliation, reform and justice, but the pace of progress, combined with contradictory government statements back home, risk undermining the confidence and trust so important to a successful outcome," the HRW observed. In fact, one point that has been emphasized in the current debate is that the international body must have established benchmarks and time-lines for Sri Lanka as a way of ensuring its commitments to the international community.
In the absence of this, there is a nagging fear that the two-year extension is nothing more than extending a process that has not even been firmly established.
Further, one would have to bear in mind that the latest Consensus Resolution on giving Colombo another two years runs the risk of becoming embroiled in the election process of 2020. With Rajapaksa hardliners keen on staging a comeback and the Sirisena group not wanting to abandon power, the net loser will be the national reconciliation process.
And heading the list of losing propositions will be a genuine probe into the civilian killings and disappearances - under the guise of national sovereignty. The world is already a witness to an 'interesting' verbal duel between former Defence Secretary Gotabaya Rajapaksa and Army Chief Sarath Fonseka on who was responsible for the 'top secret death squads' responsible for the killing of journalists and dissidents.
That there has been a change in the political environment in Sri Lanka over the last two years is there for all to see. But the question to be asked is if Colombo has used this change of atmospherics and perceptions to put in place a genuine national reconciliation process. This is going to take time as seen from other societies that have been ravaged by a civil war that took its toll in human and material terms.
To a country like India, the goings on, in a friendly neighbour State, have ramifications that are much beyond political, economic and strategic dimensions. It is also firmly entrenched in protecting the lives and livelihood of Tamils in that island nation who yearn to continue living there and with dignity.
*The author, an Assistant Professor in the Dept. of Journalism and Mass Communication of the Faculty of Science and Humanities, SRM University, Chennai, specializes on issues of Identity, Assimilation and Alienation of Indian Diaspora. Comments and suggestions on this article can be sent to [email protected]
- ‘Garbage Gazette violates FR’ BASL to seek Supreme Court ruling 3529
- Damning EU report puts GSP in doubt 3529
- I could’ve gone blind if not for Arjuna – Prof. Ariyaratne 3468
- CPC walks out en masse tomorrow Huge Opposition to Trinco Oil Tank Agreement 3471
- President arrogates powers Ultra Vires 3476
- Anti-smoking measures flop 3460
- Anti-garbage ‘mafia’ exposed 2582
- Over 200,000 expected 2367
- JVP condemns gazette notification 2353
- President’s Gazette Violates Rights – CRPS 2426
- Canberra toughens process 2354
- Police deployed to crush protests 2351
- 19 sailors barred from leaving Sri Lanka 2521
- SL maid arrested seven years later 2358
- President’s Proposals on SAITM Contradictory 2365
- Seeking sustainable development in neoliberalism 2623
- A time of gifts Settling down at Oxford 2277
- Enactment of legislation Protecting armed forces 2227
- Butterflies in my stomach 2210
- Army deserters and gun culture 2886
- LAW OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE 2891
- Super U-19 Provincial L/O Cricket Ten Provincial Teams to participate 2189
- Sri Lanka U-19 tour to Australia Fifth Youth ODI Match today 2186
- ‘Singer Cup’ U-19 Division II Inter Schools (Two Day Knock-out) Tournament Exchanges even at Maggona 2188
- Tintu, Nimali and Gayanthika to battle for 800m honours 2190
- Djokovic looking for answers after loss in Monte Carlo 2188
- Young tells United to aim high 2189
- Bekele star attraction in London with Royal touch 2189
- Windies revival frustrates Pakistan 2188
- Asian Games in Indonesia to feature 39 sports 2214
- N’Eliya Badminton C’ship from 29 April 2207
- Want Govt to Degazette wilpattu forests 3986
- Muslims rage over Mannar land 3991
- Rajitha and Naveen at cross purposes 3985
- John and Rose clash over ATDA 3984
- Betwixt political trash and mounting garbage 3985
- Jumbo killing Wildlife disaster 3982
- Sri Lanka’s loss – Australia’s gain 3089
- No garbage piles or slides then 2203
- Meethotamulla tragedy Govt accused of soft–pedalling disaster 3023
- New Constitution A lull in activities? 2248
- Ministry of Megapolis responsible for Meethotamulla TRAGEDY 2192
- Garbage crisis has reached epic proportions 2194
- MR confident of ousting govt next year – Dinesh 2877
- Marikkar pours scorn on Govt, Rajapaksas 3239
- Mahinda Rajapaksa never left the fray – MR 2863
- Solution to problems is removal of Capitalist economy 2672
- Microsoft rallies finance leaders to embrace future 2592
- SLIM elects Elangovan Karthik as new President 2594
- ikman.lk revamps ‘ikman Deals’ with new features 2590
- JWT Sri Lanka expands with ‘Fortune’ 2593
- Hirdaramani tops JASTECA awards list for 2nd year 2589
- Forbes and Walker Tea Awards 2016 Hayleys Plantations bags 20 awards 2591
- CAB Interbank Quiz to be held on 29 April 2590
- DFCC Bank new branches in Ambalantota and Wattegama 2591
- BOC Swashakthi Loans to empower entrepreneurs 2592
- SLI launches islandwide campaign 2588
- Pan Asia opens 83rd branch in Dankotuwa 2590
- Colombo City CENTRE BRINGS A CITY WITHIN A CITY 2594
- LAUGFS Car Care opens 11th Centre in Kalagedihena 2591
- Seeking sustainable development in neoliberalism 2588
- Towards the US$ 50B export target 2599
- The New Constitution Creating divisions for democracy 1720
- What is Good Governance? 1617
- Trump pushed into bombing Syria 1858
- Stallion heralds New Year 3458
- The House that Love Built 3464
- The challenges of self-representation 3454
- Solidarity Award for Prasanna Vithanage 3455
- History of Cinema 3451
- Trans national Cinematic Musical Discourse 3214
- An American Girl in a Sri Lankan World- a day of unlikely adventure 3284
- Thomas hardy – poet of time 3219
- Beware of touchy feeling! 832
- Dazzling stars illuminated 825
- G O O D L I F E D i a r i e s 829
- Cuba 822
- Science experiments A parachute 830
- ENJOY WAFFLES TO YOUR HART'S CONTENT 832
- Uniting through music 1413
- Yunho 1412
- A more complex first encounter 1417
- Hilariously delightful 1414
- Games that aren’t games 1417
- A colourful blend of young musicians 1421