UN’s Myanmar Fact-Finding Mission Raises Many Questions
BY SHENALI WADUGE
COLOMBO (IDN) - The appointment of a three-member team by the UN Human Rights Council (UNHRC) on 30 May to investigate alleged abuses by Myanmar military forces against the country's Royingya Muslim minority raises many questions about its neutrality, particularly as all the three members have questionable backgrounds as to their fitness to carry out an impartial inquiry.
The three-member panel comprises lawyers Indira Jaising from India and Radhika Coomaraswamy from Sri Lanka, and Australian human rights advocate Christopher Dominic Sidoti, according to a statement from the UNHRC.
The Mynamar government, led by Aung San Sui Kyi, has rejected such an inquiry and refused to cooperate with it. A similar approach was taken by the then Sri Lankan government of Mahinda Rajapaksa when UNHRC mounted an investigation into alleged "war crimes" by Sri Lankan armed forces in the final days of the successful push to eliminate the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE).
Myanmar needs to be wary of this committee's impartiality taking into account Sri Lanka's experience. A comment made by its chair to Al Jazeera makes it quite clear what the report is going to be.
"Minorities all over the world are facing persecution. The situation of the Rohingya community in Myanmar is especially deplorable because they face the risk of genocide," Indira Jaising told the Qatar-based channel by telephone following her appointment.
The UNHRC record sheet speaks volumes of such bias. The UN has shown by its actions and inactions that its moral right or credibility to project itself as an unbiased peace-building entity is debatable.
All three members have a record of working in cohort with western "donor" agencies that have had a record of destabilizing countries that are not subservient to western agendas, and open the path to actions aimed at regime change Indira Jaising was the Additional Solicitor General of India under the Manmohan Singh Government and she also runs a NGO called Lawyers Collective, whose license was permanently cancelled by the Indian Government in December last year for violating the Foreign Currency Regulations Act (FCRA).
The NGO had been receiving large sums of money from foreign donors like the Ford Foundation and the Open Society Foundation of George Soros. India's Home Ministry accused the NGO of using foreign contributions in a manner not mentioned in the objectives of the NGO.
Radhika Coomaraswamy is a controversial figure in Sri Lankan and at present, she is a member of the Constitutional Council set up by President Sirisena that is bowing to wishes of UNHRC for constitutional reforms.
The Global Centre is part of the International Crisis Group (ICG) set up by former Australian Foreign Minister Gareth Evans. Both Coomaraswamy and Evans were Board members of this Centre. ICES have been accused by the Peace Secretariat of carrying on a racist campaign against majority Sinhala-Buddhists under the disguise of "research" using foreign funds.
The third member of the UNHRC committee, Christopher Dominic Sidoti, was director of the International Service for Human Rights, an NGO also receiving funds from the Open Society Foundation. He visited Myanmar in August 1999 as Australia's Human Rights Commissioner.
All three appointments indicate that their final report will be slanted towards human rights activism without acknowledging the complex socio-economic and historical background to the conflict in Myanmar which is a predominantly immigration issue. Even Indian States bordering Bangladesh such as Assam have been facing similar issues.
Sri Lanka has faced a UNHRC witch hunt since winning the war against terrorism in 2009 and the forerunner to it was a similar committee set up by the UN in 2010 headed by former Indonesian Attorney General Marzuki Darusman, which did not visit the country because the Sri Lankan government refused to cooperate. It was based on third hand information and widely condemned in Sri Lanka as biased, but hailed by the international media and human rights organisations as providing proof of "war crimes".
Witch hunt gathering momentum
Apparently, a similar witch hunt is gathering momentum against Myanmar. Pressures are piling on Myanmar coming in the form of what could be termed subversive networks, reaching from the US-State Department over the United Nations to the National Endowment for Democracy, Human Rights Watch, and a cohort of Soros-funded NGOs who are bringing tremendous pressure on SuuKyi.
It is interesting to note that both Sri Lanka and Myanmar are staunchly Buddhist countries (not necessarily their governments but the people) and defenceless in the face of this onslaught. It is very clear that the Rohingya card – like the Tamil card used against Sri Lanka – is being used to destabilize Buddhist Myanmar. Both countries are also geo-politically placed in Asia, so that their support is crucial to the success of China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).
In a report published in October 2016, Singapore's S Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS) warned that the Maungdaw border attacks earlier in the month on the Myanmar Police by Rohingya militants have brought a new dimension to the conflict between the Rohingya and the Buddhist majority.
Foreign-based jihadists are taking advantage of the plight of the Rohingya in Myanmar state's Rakhine State to pursue their cause, they said, adding that the Rohingya Solidarity Organization (RSO)camps have experienced a significant influx of Al-Qaeda associated Islamist organizations and fighters.
In a report released in December 2016, the International Crisis Group warned Myanmar that Middle East trained Rohingya militants are infiltrating the country. "The insurgent group, which refers to itself as Harakah al-Yaqin (Faith Movement, HaY), is led by a committee of Rohingya émigrés in Saudi Arabia and is commanded on the ground by Rohingya with international training and experience in modern guerrilla war tactics," the report said.
"It benefits from the legitimacy provided by local and international fatwas (religious judicial opinions) in support of its cause and enjoys considerable sympathy and backing from Muslims in northern Rakhine State, including several hundred locally trained recruits," the report said.
When the UNHRC is silent on a host of western "war crimes" in the Middle East, Afghanistan and elsewhere, as well as turning a blind eye to activities of Saudi Arabia in Yemen (and now training terrorists to infiltrate Myanmar), the appointment of the investigation committee on Myanmar and its composition smacks of action on behalf of western agendas. It is time the Asian media woke up and looked at these issues in the context of China's BRI.
Asian media need to take a consistent stand on double standards practiced by the United Nations agencies and point out that if the UN takes no action against U.S.-UK-NATO crimes, they cannot insist or demand other less powerful nations accept their fact-finding missions' irrespective "colour" of its members.
*The writer is a Sri Lankan political analyst and social commentator. [IDN-InDepthNews – 7 June 2017]
Photo credit: Democracy for Burma.
IDN is flagship agency of the International Press Syndicate.
- Govt to issue fresh statement 3750
- GMOA threatens another strike 3698
- Rs 40 Bn more needed to correct flaws 4219
- Two more students arrested 3689
- Teachers threaten strike 3698
- Scot stranded in SL begs for help to return home 3698
- Return of Lanka’s boat people 3695
- GHSATD on strike 3684
- Daylight heist in Ragama 3682
- Six million in disaster prone areas 3678
- Details on Parliament vehicles withheld 3700
- Dambulla Rock Temple 3684
- India challenges China’s intentions 3687
- Surviving the Trump problem 3689
- Foreign policy geared to promoting unity –Ravi K 3686
- Strike cripples postal services 3687
- Garbage disposal facility at Puttalam 3678
- Anti-garbage drive in WP 3676
- J-SLPFL offers flood relief 3668
- Tea growers in doldrums after floods 3672
- Government takes a step back on SAITM - Ignore human nature at your peril 3889
- Ampara Muslims celebrate Ramazan on grand scale 3674
- Committee hands in its recommendations 3673
- Govt to stop SAITM enrolment and degree awards 3686
- IUSF claims leaders’ parents threatened 3083
- The march of folly Uses and instruments of disinformation 1943
- TRUMP BREAKS EID TRADITION AT WHITE HOUSE 1949
- Amsterdam – Canals, Bicycles, and Rembrandt 1948
- The Ideal of Islamic Charity 2384
- Eid-Ul-Fitr a Unique Festival Time of Joy for Muslims 2386
- Frank de Boer appointed Crystal Palace manager 3005
- SLC hires Podiatrist from Aussie 3108
- De Villiers to meet with CSA in August to decide future 3008
- Galle CC players yet to be paid 3016
- Samitha seals Bronze in Korea 3008
- Mahela dismisses report about Indian coaching job 3010
- Jayantha follows Ford’s footsteps 4051
- Akash, Taniya, Dhuwarshan, Yannik and Reshan on Top 3009
- Ricciardo wins in Baku 3007
- Coleman downed again as upsets hit trials 3006
- Social media changing our lives 1747
- Correlation between terrorism and Islam Fact or fiction? 1770
- Eid-ul-Fitr A day of thanksgiving to God in all humility 2390
- I regret introducing commercial whale watching – Ranawake 2747
- Beaten but not defeated 2731
- Railway worries and TU action 3782
- TNA jittery over TPC – C.V. Wigneswaran 2248
- TPC with a hidden agendaSeeks to weaken ITAK – Senathirajah 2153
- Lanka ranked global 5th in marine pollution– GENERAL MANAGER OF THE MARINE ENVIRONMENT PROTECTION AUTHORITY DR. TERNEY PRADEEP KUMARA 3585
- NGO funded ‘traitors’ don’t want peace in Sri Lanka – Wijeyadasa Rajapakshe 4659
- Amaranthé Bay wins ‘2017 Certificate of Excellence’ 2612
- Vespa and Aprilia SR 150 launched in Sri Lanka 2613
- The adversity of Trumponomics and Philippines goes 'Blink' 2609
- The need for a ‘Smarter Trade Strategy’ to be discussed 2610
- ThreadSol – Key to accelerating apparel exports 2608
- DR. SAMAN KELEGAMA: A STUPENDOUS CONTRIBUTION TO THE STATE, PRIVATE SECTORS 2641
- Exciting new leasing promo from Commercial Bank and United Motors 2611
- Kanrich Finance receives Carbon Conscious Certificate 2615
- Mastercard expands Labs in Asia Pacific 2613
- Sampath Bank named ‘Most Innovative Bank’ in Sri Lanka 2606
- Holistic social intervention The crying need for waste management 4483
- A time of gifts Beginning of my second year 2359
- Enlightening the younger generation 2692
- Explore what lies under the waves With the Power Ray Drone 1032
- She’s the Man: Review 1027
- Understanding Rheumatoid Arthritis 1292
- Eid-ul-Fitr A day of Love and Compassion 1298
- The Brains behind Royal and Regal 1512
- Try this when people come to you with their problems 3451
- International Yoga Day Celebration 3433
- Females born under Maha Bhagya Yoga 3446
- Latest Findings on Coconut Oil Kills Cancer in Two Days! 3712
- Birth Nakshatra says what you are – Part 4 3424
- Flying with the Flamingos Saga of the survival of the human spirit 3900
- Hindustani Vocal recital 3839
- Flying with Flamingos Literary exploration into protracted conflict 3899
- Battles and Laments 3890
- Six walks in the fictional woods 3848
- Argus-eye Indexical Dimension of Sign-Making 3826
- Pickpockets! 3641
- Haunted House 3584
- Latest lady chef in city 920
- Horton Plains invaded 1042
- Haiti 902
- GERMANY 878
- Invention of coloured crayons for kids 888
- Sri Lankan contingent to take wing 894
- Jinyoung 701
- A colourful night 697
- The story of Madura 788
- Cycling through the island 703
- It’s all about winning 710
- Flying cars soon a reality? 706
Weather today 433