Keeping the Flame of Democracy Alive
By Ranga Chandrarathne
Ceylon today Mosaic
Senior Indian journalist Geetha Seshu explores a myriad of issues that today's media has to deal with in a rapidly changing socio-cultural and political environment. Journalists across the region have to work in an increasingly hostile environment, often combating an engulfing culture of impunity and also protecting the cardinal ethics of journalism.
Q: You are an independent journalist with a special interest in reporting and analyzing media issues in particular freedom of expression, gender, media ethics and the working conditions of journalists. How would you assess the current socio-political situation in India in terms of improving freedom of expression, gender equality and empowering the working journalists to carry on their work without fear or impediment?
At the moment, the situation seems grim. Far more than in the past. There are three principal areas of tension for freedom of expression in India. First, from the State in terms of the laws that curb free speech, the restrictions imposed by the government on television channels or news publications, internet blockades and policies that continue to curb news on community radio for instance. Second, attacks by non-state actors, like vigilante groups, criminal and mafia gangs who file false defamation and other cases, attack journalists en masse or pick on individual journalists for their investigative reports. Third, the media implosion which has severely compromised journalism and rendered working journalists insecure and vulnerable to the vagaries of media owners who have indulged in rapid expansion without proper management, dubious financial investments by political and business groups into the media and who have further completely compromised ethics in journalism with paid news and PR. In this scenario, reporting on marginalized groups or issues like gender equality, violence against women, caste oppression, labour rights, the agrarian crisis, environmental norms destroyed for mega and multi-crore so-called development projects...all of this is severely constrained.
Q: You were the editor of "Soulkurry", an internet portal for women. What do you think are the major gender issues that India faces to elevate the current state of women so they may claim their rightful place in society?
'Soulkurry' was an internet portal which came up in the first dot com boom (2000) and collapsed in the dot com bust that followed. 'Soulkurry' tried to bring more women online and address their issues but in the last 17 years, the access of women to digital media in India is still woeful, latest figures, barely 20-25 per cent having access to any device, let alone access to digital media, which is crucial to freedom of expression, India still lags behind on the status of women in terms of all major parameters - health, education, literacy, mortality, sex ratio, violence and crimes against women and property or land rights,.
Q: You were also the editor of 'Humanscape', the niche social issues magazine. What was the pivotal role that the magazine played in dealing with social issues in general and gender issues in particular?
'Humanscape' was a very interesting magazine. It published as a monthly print till 2002. It was an important alternative voice and covered a gamut of issues, social, political, economic, environmental concerns, education, human rights etc. It managed to provide a platform for an amazing number of writers and columnists, most of whom wrote without any remuneration whatsoever. It was a truly unique space. Unfortunately, it was unable to sustain itself and had to close down, but for those who do recall its contribution to information and views, it played an invaluable role in highlighting social issues. It is important to remember the role played by several small magazines and publications in keeping the sprit of inquiry alive. 'Humanscape' was one of them.
Q:. You also coordinated the Free Speech Hub, an initiative of the respected mediawatch site The Hoot. (www.thehoot.org) to track freedom of expression in India. Until I read the website, I was under the impression that the culture of impunity is something that is unique to Sri Lanka. Sri Lanka has a legacy of unresolved murders of journalists such as the founding Editor-in-Chief of Sunday Leader Lasantha Wickrematunge and Prageeth Eknaligoda. A large number of Sri Lankan journalists fled the country to escape persecution. In an article 'Slow justice for murdered journalists', you have highlighted the state of journalists in India and the culture of impunity. How do you analyze this situation and what are the collective actions that journalists, rights activists can take to end the culture of impunity which has a negative impact on the democratic rights in general and freedom of expression in particular?
As I said earlier, the attacks emanate from three principal quarters and journalists need to call out and protest every one of these, in equal measure. Dogged pursuit of justice in each case is crucial. Today, as journalists are fragmented by their work environment which renders them extremely vulnerable, the task is more difficult. We need to forge ties with others in civil society, seek the help of lawyers and the legal system and citizens in general to protest impunity and the erosion of freedom of expression. We also need to raise awareness of the political forces that allow or encourage this culture of impunity.
Q: It seems that even after the murders of journalists, information regarding the murders has not been accessible to journalists, leading to the exploitation of the situation by political parties. You have pinpointed it in the report 'Journalist murders in regional media;' Television journalist Akhilesh Pratap Singh was shot dead in Chhatra, Jharkhand barely 24 hours later, in neighboring Bihar, Rajdeo Ranjan, Siwan bureau chief of the Hindi daily 'Hindustan', was gunned down in Siwan. This continuous spree of killings poses a serious threat to the fundamental democratic values and very notion of justice. Is India increasing becoming a dangerous territory for journalists to work in?
Yes, if one goes merely by the data, the scenario is alarming. Essentially, anyone who pushes the envelope and contours of safe and bland reportage and ventures to do any kind of investigative journalism, is in danger of attack. The complete lack of accountability by law enforcing agencies to their task of investigation of crimes and booking of perpetuators is a dangerous situation.
Q: In the same report, you have mentioned the role played by politics in creating such a dangerous atmosphere for journalists. How could these negative trends be arrested in order to improve the working condition of journalists and to ensure their safety in the line of duty?
Political parties, without exception, attack the media when they perceive it is unfavorable to them. On the other hand, political parties also have their own media vehicles or cultivate sections of the media as their own. Apart from granting advertising to favourable media houses, the state also offers sops to media-workers in terms of subsidies, housing schemes for journalists and other such favors. The working conditions of journalists need to improve in terms of their security of tenure, contractualisation must stop, collective bargaining principles must be restored to better their working conditions and they need insurance cover, training and support when they venture out to cover conflict. If media managements even acknowledge that the journalist killed in the line of duty was on their staff, instead of pretending (despite the evidence of identity cards and appointment letters) perhaps we can ensure dignity of the working journalist!
Q: One of the major areas of concerns is sensitive gender issues and media ethics. You have raised the issues of media ethics regarding the publication of a picture in 'Mumbai Mirror' under the headline "Commoditizing Tragedy?" How would you revisit the ethical and rights issues in the incident?
I think the main concern is that, with more invasive media, we need to be more conscious of how we use our power to record and report events. Of course, journalists will shoot pictures and visually capture events and transmit them in real time. We need to be much more conscious of how we do so and how those caught in the vortex of actual events will view themselves later through the media's image of them. These are ethical and philosophical questions and we need to review our practice continuously. In this particular case, the manner in which the photograph was used by this publication's excessive blowing up of the picture was totally avoidable.
Q: Media ethics is a perennial issue that questions not only the way in which one newspaper reports on a particular incident, but also the degree of objectivity that it displays in reporting and the unbiased nature of media as a whole. 'Dubious ethics in Bengaluru assault reporting, the media hypes up racism, but who will call out the racism that the 'Deccan Chronicle' and others displayed'. Bengaluru assault report is a classic case. How would you analyze the case and what are the major issues that should be dealt with regarding the manner and the content of the reporting by several newspapers?
The media must be conscious of its role and refrain from feeding into biases and prejudices. India's media hardly examines racism in Indian society, even the obsession with a fair skin, let alone towards members of the North East or the blacks. Now, with these incidents, and the exodus and attacks on the North East students, the media is forced to cover these incidents. Its coverage has been found wanting in several instances. The other problem is the race to sensationalize to get more TRPs, because of which fairness, fact-checking and accuracy are compromised.
- Angry President says Enough is enough
- Sirisena tells Cabinet why SC opinion sought To plan development projects accordingly
- BASL to meet Prez and PM Regarding detrimental statements made by politicos
- Tipsy tussle Cabinet withdraws gazette notification Ban on sale of alcohol to women to remain
- DWC, Police & Armed Forces unite National plan to tackle wildlife related crimes
- NCPA employees union claims: Protector of children employing abuser EANCPA urges Govt to put in place a Child Protection System
- 88-year -old mother of 4 left for dead Bandaragama Police saves the day
- Rejection of SLPP Maharagama MC nominations Court to hear petitions on 19th
- National Child Protection Authority Certain officials under-qualified – Employees Union
- Puzzled by electoral system & disillusioned Public not keen on voting – SANASA
- Malik visits Geneva SL to engage with WEF
- Bond scam debate debacle COPE Chair criticizes Govt
- Threat of further inflationary pressure MER at its lowest
- Edu, info and outreach essential in legislation to ban FGC - Sahiyo
- Cooperation in IT & Electronics Govt signs MoU with India
- Police arrest school bus driver Sans licence, with disabled elbow and hearing defect
- Indian Minister calls on President
- PR Anthonis Memorial Oration on 22 Jan
- LG polls Rival candidate disrupts TNA meeting
- Navy nab 16 Indian fishers
- `Jallicut’ in Kilinochchi
- Thanks giving to reservoir
- Students mark Thai Pongal
- APPGT calls on SL Govt Implement UNHRC resolution
- Aussie U’grads visit SEUSL
- Havies dominate Army
- Djokovic and Sharapova back in business
- Mahrez worth over £100m to Leicester Puel
- Man United put Sanchez saga aside to see off Stoke
- Stokes charged with affray over nightclub fight
- Kiwis win again
- Death of K.Mathivanan’s mother
- Jithara wins double crown
- SLC provides equipment to 14 Clubs
- MCA ‘C’ Division – 50 Overs League Chandula shines for Kanrich Finance
- KDHA 7-a-side hockey Old Kingswoodians emerge champions
- Virat Kohli fined
- Royal Rugby Fiesta on 21 January
- ‘Chandika can’t score runs or take wickets’
- Sri Lanka eying new era
- Du Plessis makes slow progress
- 12th ICC Under-19 Cricket World Cup v
- ‘Singer Cup’ U-19 Cricket Gurukula home for lunch
- Parents and coaches criticize SLTT Failure to distribute Rs 1.2 million
- Selection of volleyball coaches Law violators to attend Interview?
- India and Sri Lanka expand IT cooperation
- edotco launches Sri Lanka’s first Smart Lamp Pole on Marine Drive
- Sri Lanka’s e-Commerce transactions up 28% YoY in December: Visa
- Say Hello to 2018 with Emirates
- AIA Real Rewards sees over 7,000 winners in 2017
- Arpico’s ‘Insurance for the living’
- Germany to add China’s yuan to currency reserves
- Lanka Tiles awarded for Social Dialogue and Workplace Collaboration
- The digitization of marketing: A closer look
- eZ Cash rolls out first phase of ATMs in the North
- Islamic Finance Forum, South Asia HNB Al Najaah bags 3 awards
- PickMe recognized at e-Swabhimani Awards
- Ultimate Motorworks launches workshop for high-end vehicles
- Allianz Sisu Diriya scholarships for Grade 5 exam toppers
- Ceylon Leather Products relaunches DI brand
- CATIC holds New Year sports function for China - SL friendship
- NDB relocates Ratnapura branch
- Most Asian markets edge higher
- 2017 apparel earnings to hit $4.7 B Rishad
- SL fails to stick to two IMF benchmarks
- Imposing Civic Liability for the Bond Scam
- With rebel ceasefire in tatters Fears of fresh displacement in Colombia –UN
- The March of Folly Dr. Ranjith Atapattu, an exemplary figure
- Liberia’s development at risk
- Politicos’ image plummets to lowest ebb
- What’s up with the weather?
- Gay and intersex asylum seekers Britain safe haven from persecution
- ‘We don’t want to fool the Sinhalese and get our dues’
- Rohingya insurgents say 10 found in Myanmar grave ‘innocent civilians’
- Thalaivar’s New Avatar
- Upcoming LG Elections a referendum
- No political solution for Tamil grievances in sight – Ananthy Sasitharan
- Division in SLFP main reason for UNP victory
- We don’t endorse Basil’s leadership
- Rogues in all Govts should be punished- Akila Viraj Kariyawasam
- National Prosperity Turning the Tide
- Disposable coffee cups:British lawmakers call for “latte levy”
- If only we could crackdown on the root causes to effect sustainable solutions Herein lies a Nation’s progress
- Planetary combines that foreshadow misfortune for father
- Pirith chants for abundant harvest
- Venus into Capricorn
- Vastu and Domestic Animals
- Yoga for Children and Adults with Disabilities
- Notes on history: The thinkers and the doers
- Reflections on a nation of non-readers
- The Disaster Artist: The (un)making of a movie
- Our children and our cinema
- INTERPRETING ASIAN CINEMA: CHALLENGES AHEAD
- How Sanskrit journalism is slowly hogging headlines
- ice manufacturing in South Asia
- CMSC’s season finale concert
- Kite Surfing Lanka Kalpitiya An experience of a lifetime
- Ella and mini Adam’s Peak
- A cave of history -Ravana Cave
- Trump’s ‘madman’ ACT scared N. Korea to talks
- Calls for ‘revenge’ Israeli settler killed in attack
- Banning of Colombo Journal First English Newspaper
- Sri Lankan author publishes for the world
- Broadway brought to our own shores
- Celebrating the harvest