The March of Folly The urgent need of an independent public service
The National Human Resources Development Council has recently set up a Committee to look at new ways of working in the Public Sector. I have been appointed to chair this, which makes sense because I have been writing for some time now about the need for radical reform in this field, and suggesting ways in which things should change. This is essential if the country is not to continue to decline irrevocably. But I am obviously not the only person who senses a deep malaise in the country as a whole.
Recent comments by Prof. Siri Hettige, who had been appointed to chair the Police Commission, after the passing of the 19th Amendment, are depressing to read, for he thinks that 'The government seems to have lost direction' and that 'We have run out of viable political options'.
There is little doubt that this government is on its last legs but, as he suggests, a reversion to what we had before will not help matters. The recent catastrophe with regard to Uma Oya, and revelations about the manner in which a disastrous project was thrust upon the nation, make clear that the last Government also allowed corruption to inflict irreparable damage upon us. We knew this and that was why, even though it had achieved a great success with regard to the gravest problem facing the country, it was rejected at the polls. But given that this government has proved even more corrupt, and wasteful, and 'is not making any headway', as Prof. Hettige puts it, with regard to development, clearly many people are beginning to feel that those in charge previously would do a better job than those making decisions now.
I think so too and, as I put it two years ago, even though I think Maithripala Sirisena was the right choice for the Presidency, a government under him led by Mahinda Rajapaksa was a better option than one led by Ranil Wickremesinghe. The President too, seemed to think this was the case, when he gave Mahinda Rajapaksa nomination, but then panic set in. The problem was that those around Maithripala, who had failed to support him at a time of difficulty, poisoned his mind about Mahinda, while those around Mahinda kept declaring that Maithri would be got rid of, which exacerbated the latter's fears. So, we ended up with Ranil, even though he is disliked intensely by a majority of the people in the country, and indeed several leading lights in the UNP who see him as a Pied Piper, leading them into disaster for the third time.
While I find Ranil's hypocrisy and incompetence, combined with a serene belief in his own capacities, quite abhorrent, I think however, that we must look beyond individuals to the structural changes that the country needs. The last government made several commitments in this regard in its manifesto, but nothing has been done about these save a few cosmetic changes through the 19th Amendment.
I have noted previously that the failure to change the electoral system was perhaps the worst blunder the government made. The President has declared recently that it breeds corruption, so it is sad that he did not abide by his commitment to ensure that it was changed before the last general election.
It is still not too late for him to ensure change in this regard, but he must realize that nothing will be done if he continues with Ranil as Prime Minister.
But there are other matters too, of vital importance which have been ignored. The commitment to ensurean independent public service for instance was undermined at its heart when government failed to change the provision that ensures that Permanent Secretaries give up office when there is a change of government. That provision, leaving Secretarial appointments in the hands of the President alone, in effect allows new ministers to bring in people they like instead of sticking with those with experience.
A crying example of this is what happened with regard to Rehabilitation and Resettlement, where the hopelessly incompetent Swaminathan got rid of his able Secretary, Sivagnanasothy. Recently Sugathadasa, who had been Secretary previously of Resettlement, but been removed when Swaminathan became minister, was also suddenly changed. He had been rehabilitated as it were by being made Secretary of Tourism, but has now been moved to health.
This may benefit health, but it leaves tourism, another area that needs a good Secretary, once again in the lurch.
Why we need good and experienced Secretaries is precisely because so many ministers are incompetent, and have little interest in a professional approach to the subjects entrusted to them. I suppose that is a problem in other dispensations too, that follow the Westminster system, but nowhere else are those who will lead governments prevented from picking able people to be elected as Members of Parliament.
Only here does a perverse electoral system privilege many without intellectual ability or administrative talent, provided only that they can gather large numbers of preference votes – a target achieved by spending vast amounts of money and gaining name recognition through publicity wholly unrelated to ability.
And even in countries where parties can select able people to constituencies, given that there will be some not soable people elected, there are capable officials entrenched in position. They are able then to guide those endowed with powers in a sector they know nothing about, and without much or even any administrative experience or capacity.
In the think piece I have prepared then for our Committee, I have given priority to developing suggestions that will promote continuity, on the grounds that 'At present policies and plans and projects are adversely affected by changes of personnel, notably when Ministries change, but also simply when those in charge change jobs. Possible improvements are – Mechanisms to make Ministry Secretaries Permanent. This should not preclude changes for good reason, but there should be reasons adduced. For this, a special committee of the PSC should have responsibility. Requesting reasons even for changes lower down would be useful.
Ensuring proper handover procedures when personnel do change. It is also desirable to make sure that all senior ministry personnel are kept abreast of ministry activity. At present not all ministries have regular senior staff meetings to share information about programmes and also understand how they are inter-related.
Regulations with regard to advisory bodies to ensure again that there are no sudden changes, and that even when changes occur there is a critical mass of experience so that new personnel are well briefed.'
I suspect that ministers however, will be against strengthening the position of Secretaries now, since they seem to hold powers of life and death over them, they find it easier to bend them to their will. And sadly even those ministers who are not intrinsically corrupt find it convenient to have, as Chief Accounting Officers of their ministries, individuals they can intimidate.
The incident happened in the time of President Kumaratunga, another of whose favourites, Duminda Dissanayake, has it seems allowed millions to be squandered now on hiring a building for his ministry and then not using it. But we know that similar excesses occurred too, in the time of the last government, and that there is little to choose between them with regard to either corruption or culpable extravagance.
Instead of trading accusations then, we should be working on systems that prevent or at least limit such abuse. I know this will not stop such plundering at once but, given that those who are responsible in theory for public money, the Secretaries to Ministries, have no job security, restoring this would be at least a step in the right direction.
- Struggle against ISIS in Central Asia A reverse side 3811
- Populism and industrial policy 3277
- Police need to toughen up 3866
- Emirati pilot makes donation 3313
- Programme on prevention of NCD’s 3400
- JO’s efforts to destroy Govt wont succeed – Nimal Siripala 3297
- 37 injured in two bus related mishaps 3278
- Five nabbed with heroin 3278
- China for military boost with SL 3310
- Batti Youth drowns trying to escape the STF 3298
- Canada welcomes reconciliation efforts 3287
- Ball lies in Govt’s court – SIA 3291
- MR warns about OMP 3293
- Police uncover all 4739
- IF Ravi K will continue as Minister – Bandula 3338
- Aloysius complies with PC order 3274
- CPC on Strike 3290
- Army moves into Maldivian parliament 3277
- GMOA on strike today 3269
- Ravi K’s luxury apartment paid for by Arjun Aloysius Director of EW Properties Plc submits documents describing transaction 3980
- What Next For US-Europe Trade Policy? 3964
- How to interpret the crisis between Qatar and Saudi Arabia’s allies 3262
- GOSL SHOULDN’T TOLERATE HIGH-HANDED ARROGANCE 4129
- Judge pays tribute to dead Sergeant 3176
- Minister Samarasinghe visits Oluvil 3163
- Can the unity govt deliver? 2993
- The March of Folly Creating Better Members of Parliament 2789
- Natural Remedies to Prevent Illnesses 2720
- European powers’ domination of the world 2575
- Do we need a new constitution? 3475
- Navodya and Thathsarani finish fifth 3270
- Hiruni, Cooray and Nimali make the cut 3346
- Tillakaratne appointed temporary batting coach 3273
- Ashwin hails India's rise to top Test ranking 3271
- Rahul out of first Test with fever 3268
- Spieth has Grand Slam in sights 3267
- Jamaicans stun Mexico 3262
- Froome wins fourth Tour de France 3268
- Man United edges Real Madrid on penalty kicks 3270
- Heartbreak for Kariyawasam Finishes fourth with personal best 2589
- Animals to lose peace and quiet at night? 4849
- Right of Reply 4733
- Addressing dengue One hour, one day and every week is enough 5532
- Acute water crisis grips Jaffna Ponies dying of thirst in Delft 4733
- NLB’s alleged monopoly continues 4767
- NFTH to Facilitate Clinical Training for SAITM 4119
- Prioritize FTAs with China and India – Dr. Wignaraja 3444
- Private medical education fraught with corruption – Prof. Carlo Fonseka 2499
- MULTINATIONALS HAVE SOUNDED DEATH KNELL FOR LOCAL TRISHAW INDUSTRY 4651
- NFTH – a red herring exercise in deception 2534
- Nationwide inflation down to 6.3% in June 3276
- Importers urge legislation apt to modern business 3272
- Fitch affirms ratings of 10 finance companies 3278
- Sri Lanka Economic Summit 2017 begins today 3277
- Government agencies review Port City progress 3277
- Belt and Road presents both opportunities and challenges 3274
- Asian markets mixed as dollar trades at lowest levels in a year 3268
- Shares down to near 7-week low 3271
- CB continues to buy dollars to build reserves 3292
- Cambio launches IT learning centre 3264
- A Whitewash for Failed Politics 2515
- Mattek-Sands horror injury puts Djokovic, Federer in shadow 3061
- Maidens Bowling Overs 2052
- Spider-Man: Homecoming Review 2058
- The Tale of Android 2066
- An effective local medicine for Dengue 2043
- Kebella for High Blood Pressure Prevents fat from clogging veins 1912
- Turmeric the heavenly medicine 1907
- Nadi Dosha – an evil that ruins married life– Part 2 1107
- Next four months will be crucial 1099
- Rahu in the 7th obstructs marital life? 1095
- Agate gemstones keep mind and body balance 1070
- There is no success or failure in Love 1075
- Radiobeiträge Radio as Potent Tool of Education 4815
- Speaking with a Forked Tongue 4818
- Global and Local in Hong Kong cinema -Part 2 4848
- Kuchipudi dance recital and Carnatic vocal recital 4800
- Fairway National Literary Awards 2017 4734
- PASCH International Youth Camp 2017 in Embilipitiya Holistic Approach to Education 4789
- History Can Guide us Towards Prosperous Lives 4741
- Melancholia and the Creative Urge 6551
- An endemic cure for snake bite 1103
- Summer holiday camp for kids 1110
- Shouldn’t they live too? 1090
- The dearth of skilled labour in the hospitality sector 1080
- The importance of grooming your pet 1074
- The new face of tea 1093
- Charging victory 1086
- An amazing biking experience 1103
- Young masters of Karate 1097
- Skills for all 1070
- The words,sound and legacy of Chester Bennington 1090
- Marching in celebration 1082