Salient features of a new Constitution
by Lakshman I. Keerthisinghe
The glory of justice and the majesty of law are created not just by the Constitution – nor by the Courts – nor by the officers of the law – nor by the lawyers – but by the men and women who constitute our society – who are the protectors of the law as they are themselves protected by the law. – Robert Kennedy
It has been reported that the Mahanayaka Theras of the three Nikayas and other Sangha Sabhas who convened in Kandy, unanimously decided that there was no need to bring in a new Constitution or an Amendment to the Constitution. Their fears appear to be based on the premise that an attempt is being made by interested parties to bring in the features of a federal State in the new Constitution thereby doing away with the unitary state and deprive the place that Buddhism enjoys in the present Constitution.
In the above backdrop this article attempts to analyzse the salient features of a new Constitution, which would gain the approval of a majority of Sri Lankans at a referendum. Without facing a referendum a new Constitution cannot be framed. The Framework Resolution of 9 March 2016 created a representative body known as the Constitutional Assembly (CA) whereby all 225 Members of Parliament sit as a committee for the purpose of drafting a Constitutional Proposal.
The CA is chaired by the Speaker of Parliament and is aided by seven Deputy Chairmen who have been elected by the Assembly to chair sittings in his absence. In preparing the Draft Constitutional Proposal for consideration of the CA, the Steering Committee is aided by six Sub-Committees. The Sub-Committees were appointed by the CA to deliberate on areas of fundamental rights, judiciary, law and order, public finance, public service, and centre-periphery relations. The recommendations contained in the final reports by the sub-committees are to be considered by the Steering Committee in drafting constitutional proposals on the respective subject areas. The 'Final Report' of the Steering Committee and the 'Draft Constitutional Proposal' will be subject to deliberation and debate by the CA.
Draft Constitutional Proposal
The Final Report incorporating approved amendments will be submitted to the CA thereafter, together with the Draft Constitutional Proposal containing the actual text of a Constitution for Sri Lanka. If the CA approves the Draft Constitutional Proposal by a two-thirds majority, it will be submitted to the Cabinet of Ministers. The Draft Constitutional Proposal will also be presented to Parliament.
Thereafter, the CA will stand dissolved. With the dissolution of the CA, the Draft Constitutional Proposal would be converted to a Bill for consideration by Parliament in accordance with the scheme laid out in the Second Republican Constitution of 1978 for formally enacting a new Constitution for Sri Lanka.
The report of the Public Representations Committee (PRC) quotes what Prof. Marasinghe said in 2003 in foresight: "We have reached such a stage here in Sri Lanka, where it has now become necessary to arrive at a constitutional settlement which would not only provide cast iron constitutional guarantees to all persons equally, which human ingenuity could devise, but also provide the legal institutions that could protect and enforce those guarantees. Unless that is achieved now, this nation would have lost yet another opportunity to solve its ethnic conflict which might in its next phase wrench the country apart," which is true indeed.
The PRC report states that while Buddhism is given the foremost place, Hinduism, Islam and Christianity should enjoy equal rights. It must be noted that in Saudi Arabia no religion other than Islam is permitted to be practised. The Kandyan Convention of 1815 entered into between the British and the Chieftains in Article 5 stated: "The religion of Buddhism is declared inviolable and its rights to be maintained and protected," in acceptance of the unique status Buddhism enjoyed under the Sinhalese Kings.
Advent of Buddhism
From the advent of Buddhism in Sri Lanka it has been given the foremost place and protected by all subsequent kings. Even during the colonial period all attempts to suppress Buddhism failed. For instance, Buddhism was not taught in government schools, disregarded as idolatry under missionary influence and Vesak was not given any special significance until 1885 when it was declared a public holiday, in response to a sustained campaign of agitation by the Buddhist public and the Sangha. Thus Section 29 of the Soulbury Constitution enshrined a principle that even the British did not necessarily uphold in practice either in Britain or in any of its colonies, despite public declarations of a commitment to the ideal of a secular State.
For example, in England the British monarchy i.e. the Queen, is officially declared as the defender of the faith i.e. Christian faith, and in spite of Britain being a multi-religious society, the laws against blasphemy operate only when the Christian religion is denigrated or ridiculed. Only days of religious significance to Christians have been made public holidays in Britain whereas in Sri Lanka all important days of religious significance of all four religions Buddhism, Hinduism, Christianity and Islam have been declared public holidays. The Constitution should also recognize it as the supreme law of the country.
Supremacy of the Constitution
To ensure the supremacy of the Constitution, all action inconsistent with the Constitution must be considered void. Removal of executive presidency should not mean transferring all the executive powers to the Prime Minister and creating an authoritarian executive Prime Minister. While the President should have certain powers to ensure checks and balances the functions of Parliament, the Prime Minister should be answerable to Parliament and the President.
It has been stated that the denial of language rights formed the basis for the ethnic conflict in Sri Lanka. The language issue has grown to such proportions as to bring the country to the verge of total destruction. It is acceptable that the new Constitution should recognize tri-lingual administration at the centre to avoid language discrimination. Every non-Sinhalese citizen should have the right to services and communication in their own language, either in Tamil or English, with access to translators.
The Sub Committee on Fundamental Rights has recommended that the fundamental rights chapter should be strengthened and made consistent with Sri Lanka's international human rights obligations and should also include social, economic, cultural, group, women's and children's rights apart from strengthening civil and political rights. Provisions must be included in the new Constitution to ensure judicial independence which means that judges are not subject to pressure and influence, and are free to make impartial decisions based solely on fact and law.
Devolution of power
Although properly devised, devolution of power would be the major starting point towards reconciliation, the unitary State of the country should be preserved. The Constitution should specifically state that the Sri Lankan State is sovereign, unitary, undivided and indivisible. It should specify that no Provincial Council or other authority may declare any part of the territory of Sri Lanka to be a separate State or advocate or take steps towards the secession of Province or part thereof, from Sri Lanka.
There should be provisions to strengthen the institutions dealing with justice in the country such as the judiciary, the Attorney General's Department, the Bribery Commission, the Police by the provision of sufficient human and material resources to prevent delays in the administration of justice.
In conclusion, it must be appreciated that as Robert Kennedy stated and quoted at the outset: "The glory of justice and the majesty of law are created not just by the Constitution ...but by the men and women who constitute our society, who are the protectors of the law as they are themselves protected by the law." It must be noted that as Abraham Lincoln stated, "We the people are the rightful masters of both Congress and the Courts, not to overthrow the Constitution but to overthrow the men who pervert the Constitution," and the people of Sri Lanka would not hesitate to act in a similar manner.
The writer is an Attorney-at-Law with LLB, LLM, MPhil (Colombo)
Solution must be acceptable to Tamils Separate State is not a reasonable request - Former Army Commander, General Gerry De Silva RWP, VSV, USP
If we join with the govt then the vote will tilt to the JVP or people will abstain from voting We have to form a new party!
- Moscow’s Middle East Resurgence
- How the UK Always Plays Ireland
- SEUSL gets a ‘Hela Bojun’ outlet
- BRT system could solve transport issues – Dr Gunaruwan
- Rajitha call for unity to eradicate malaria
- Foreign Investments strengthen Reserves
- Five arrested for attacking students
- Russian drowns in Hikkaduwa
- Inflation in 2017:Inclement weather to blame - CBSL
- Hasen Ali quits SLMC for UPA
- PC Amendment Act Bathiudeen unhappy
- Dayasiri blasts Janayugaya
- Recognizing Jerusalem as Israeli capital:SPPFA criticizes Trump
- Sriyani pledges to support President Quits JO due to neglect
- 25% Women representation Faiszer blasts opposing Ministers
- Most Ven. Prajnananda Maha Thero dead
- Railway strike to continue Talks with Kariyawasam not fruitful - Dodangoda
- Opposition failed to criticize Budget– Harsha
- Air Force X’mas Carols
- Prof. Hapuarachchi accepts responsibility, says: ‘Mawbima’ news item is correct
- Railway Unions adamant Despite essential service declaration
- UN’s CAT OP effective from 4 Jan
- H’tota Port officially handed over to China First tranche of US$ 294 M paid yesterday
- Supply of coconuts to Army Treasury faces huge loss
- Budget passed with 99 majority
- Lakmal stars in Sri Lanka’s victory
- Asia Rugby U-19 Hong Kong trounce Sri Lanka
- Premier League Club Cricket BRC and Colts win
- Dialog Champions League Emma scores hat-trick
- Army SC in hard fought win
- ‘Singer Cup’ U-19 Cricket Match drawn at Moratuwa
- 12th Singapore Nationals Lankan Synchro swimmers excel
- England draw warm-up match
- Shakib named new Bangladesh Test captain
- Dr. Lucas wins gold medals
- Truax shocks DeGale with majority decision
- Southee, Boult dominate for Kiwis
- James carries Cavs, Clippers edge Wizards
- Conte concedes title chances are gone
- Lowry-McDowell share lead
- MAS boxers dominate
- Turkey: Nearly 70 journalists on trial in one week
- Havelocks win a tight game
- Sri Lanka can rise to the occasion
- Singer Cup’ Under-19 Schools Cricket Rahula and S. Thomas’ win
- Fiscal Liability Act in Parliament in Jan
- First tranche of us$ 294 M for Hambantota Port Boost for foreign reserves, imports- cb Governor
- ‘Ports and Shipping Ministry ranked least efficient’
- Finance Company bad loans up 11.5%
- Dilshan Wirasekara elected to CSE Board
- The Jobs Numbers: US employers add 228,000 new jobs Last updated: 8 December 2017
- Stocks rally as dollar posts best week this year
- Nikkei leads Asia markets higher on Friday
- World Bank says Government lacks the will
- Lessons for WTO from EU’s ‘differentiated integration’
- Global powers lobby to stop ‘special’ Brexit deal
- WTO summit What you need to know
- US jobs growth stronger than expected
- WTO won’t survive Recognizing China as a Market Economy
- China has one big advantage
- Offline and online integration delightful customer journeys
- New investors for operational Port
- tea, rubber, spice exports to Korea soon President slams Diplomats for not promoting exports Says many countries aren’t aware SL produces tea, rubber Navin eyes 40% Chinese market share, from current 25%
- TI Cycles to buy two Lankan firms for $3.3M
- Two shortlisted for BOC’s new GM/CEO post
- Local Govt elections: Dilemma of the voter People get the leaders they deserve - Joseph de Maistre
- From stifling the freedom of expression A culture of accountability need of the hour To deal with the culture of impunity that pervades Sri Lankan institutions
- Concretes & Abstracts Pogrom in the Penitentiary & T.S. Elliot
- FRANCHISE DELAYED IS FRANCHISE DENIED
- Books the potent portable medium
- Sampanthan’s unique role
- United nations warns:No hasty returns of Rohingya to Myanmar!
- New Constitution Altering Territorial Boundaries
- Sale of migrants as slaves in Libya May be crime against humanity UN
- Trimble Inc land survey contract Surveyors cry foul, but accused of inefficiency
- Railway tracks cheaper than highways
- Delimitation process Public response quite low – Dr. K. Thavalingam
- Solution must be acceptable to Tamils Separate State is not a reasonable request - Former Army Commander, General Gerry De Silva RWP, VSV, USP
- We are moving forward whilst clashing with each other
- Transport systems Cheaper and efficient solutions needed – Prof. Kumarage
- Alleged human rights violations Lord Naseby defends Sri Lanka
- Tourists least concerned about liquor availability Reducing the price of beer a blunder! A gateway to all other drugs
- Plantar fasciitis That Intolerable Heel Ache
- Neecha Dosha of planets and how it is cancelled Neechabhanga Rajayoga
- Vastu defects and bathrooms
- Are you endowed with Pancha Maha PurushaYoga?
- God Aiyanayake: Guardian Deity of Jungle and Village
- Good thoughts eliminate bad planetary influence
- The Disaster Artist: The (un)making of a movie
- Our children and our cinema
- INTERPRETING ASIAN CINEMA: CHALLENGES AHEAD
- How Sanskrit journalism is slowly hogging headlines
- ice manufacturing in South Asia
- CMSC’s season finale concert
- Two documentaries on Sri Lanka in Film South Asia 2017
- Politics of nostalgia
- Kite Surfing Lanka Kalpitiya An experience of a lifetime
- Ella and mini Adam’s Peak
- A cave of history -Ravana Cave
- Silvia Senanayake Dazzles at Mrs. Asia International
- Let’s Taco Colombo
- THE WRITER’S KITCHENNETTE MULLED WINE
- Hunger gnaws at Rohingya Children in camps
- Defeating IS Russia has ‘accomplished’ task
- Saudi Princess Ameera Aidan fights sex exploitation
- Hacking into the gate
- Review: A Bad Moms Christmas Relatable holiday humour
- A must watch superhero film!