Enter Arjuna Mahendran!
By Kavindya Chris Thomas
After Arjun Aloysius's daring escape last week, it was the former Central Bank Governor Arjuna Mahendran's turn to take the witness box to give evidence before the Presidential Commission of Inquiry into the issuance of Treasury Bonds at the Central Bank. And that's exactly what happened this week which saw several previously surfaced matters arising once again, following the conclusion of Perpetual Treasuries Ltd CEO Kasun Palisena's evidence.
On Tuesday (19) Mahendran's testimony began after his counsel claimed that he would testify, although not being legally required to so, as he is a 'foreign citizen'.
Mahendran's Counsel Romesh de Silva PC making a statement prior to the witness's arrival claimed that his client is giving his testimony, as a Singaporean citizen, to prove his innocence and to support the Commission. He also added that his client should be treated with "respect, dignity and decorum" when cross-examined by counsel of the Attorney General's office, failing which he reserves the right to withdraw from the proceedings at any point.
The Commission acknowledging the statement responded that Mahendran will be treated as every other witness who appeared before the Commission, with utmost respect. Accordingly, Mahendran's testimony wasled by his Counsel where he moved to establish clarifications on several allegations which had been levelled against him.
On the following day – Wednesday (20) – however, the Commission issued an order stating that despite the fact that the former Governor holds Singaporean citizenship, he is not outside the law of the country. The Chairperson of the Commission, Supreme Court Judge K. T. Chitrasiri, reading out the order, said "Mahendran being a foreign citizen does not take him outside our jurisdiction and he had to obey the summons. Especially after accepting the appointment as the Governor of the Central Bank of Sri Lanka (CBSL), Mahendran cannot claim that he is outside of our law."
Commissioner Chitrasiri further conceded that Mahendran cannot take the same position Perpetual Treasuries Arjun Aloysius took previously, where he refused to give evidence on the basis that he might be incriminating himself. The Commission noted that compelling Aloysius to give evidence could have led to a review of the case in Superior Courts. Noting that Mahendran cannot resort to the same position, the Commission claimed that his evidence will continue as usual. The Commission made the order to clarify their actions, in the face of recent media reports.
Not held any positions
Mahendran testifying before the Commission noted that prior to his appointment as the CBSL Governor, he had vacated the directorial positions of all the companies he had chaired. He also said he had not held any positions while holding the Governor's positions and had not maintained shares from other companies too.
Mahendran's Counsel also said that his client had maintained an 'open door policy' during his tenure at the CBSL, where he had had a casual relationship with his colleagues.
However, he also noted that after taking up the position he had been informed of a Rs 39 billion loss since 2013 and 2014 at the CBSL, which he had remedied by reconstructing several departments. Accordingly, he had established three clusters which were divided among the three Deputy Governors.
On his relationship with his son-in-law Arjun Aloyisus, of the Perpetual Treasuries Ltd., Mahendran was asked whether he had discussed official matters with him on any occasion. This he completely denied. He also noted that the fact that Aloysius had married his daughter back in 2012 was common knowledge among the country's decision-makers as many politicians and members of the business community had been present at the wedding.
The case of the letter
The issue regarding the meeting between Mahendran, then Finance Minister Ravi Karunanayake, Minister Kabir Hashim and Malik Samarawickrama was also brought up. Here Mahendran claimed that the meeting that took place on 26 February – one day prior to the controversial Treasury Bond auction – was to inform the CBSL of the Government's requirement of Rs 75 billion for uncompleted road development projects. Consequently, he noted that he had requested a letter confirming this meeting from Karunanayake prior to his appearance before the second Committee on Private Enterprises (COPE) in June 2016.
This matter surfaced initially when Karunanayake was giving evidence before the Commission earlier this year. The issue of this undated letter was questioned and was clarified as to have been an oversight according to the former Finance Minister.
On Friday during the cross-examination of Mahendran the matter of the letter resurfaced. Acting Solicitor General de Livera alleged there's an 'absolute contradiction' in the statement made to Parliament by Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe on 17 March 2015 and a letter issued by the former Finance Minister Ravi Karunanayake with regard to funds said to have been requested from the Central Bank.
De Livera went as far as to suggest that Mahendran had "concocted" his testimony about two Government Ministers, namely Karunanayake and Kabir Hashim, asking the Central Bank to raise Rs 75 billion for urgent road development projects, leading up to the 27 February 2015 auction.
The Prime Minister had in his statement, de Livera recollected, that there had been an urgent funding requirement of Rs 15 billion, which he said was a 'glaring contradiction' to Karunanayake's statement in the letter. Mahendran disagreed, claiming that there had been references to medium-term and short-term requirements. Rs 15 billion had been initially needed by at least the beginning of the following week, and a further Rs 75 billion subsequently.
At this point, de Livera accused Mahendran of lying, calling this particular testimony a material contradiction. Citing testimony by senior Treasury officials who, according to de Livera, had said there was no documentation for such a request to their knowledge.
Mahendran denied this.
Asked if Mahendran still advances his assertion that there was this urgent funding requirement in the face of "all this evidence," the former Governor said it was "verbally indicated" to him by the ministers and that it was on the back of his mind on 27 February, the day of the auction.
On the day of the auction
When he was being led on the evidence, Mahendran relayed the occurrences that took place on the day of the auction. He claimed that he visited the Public Debt Department while the auction was ongoing in order to see the results. On both occasions, he had been accompanied by several other officers including two Deputy Governors. He highlighted that until he received the bid sheet later that day he had not been aware of the identity of the bidders in the auction.
Mahendran claimed that the allegations being made against him, by the Attorney General's Department, are based on factually incorrect assumptions which he went on to clarify.
It was during the cross-examination of evidence however, where it was suggested that Mahendran had interfered with the due process in the 27 February 2015 Treasury Bond auction, thereby influencing its outcome. The allegations were completely denied by Mahendran. He claimed that bids were accepted in concurrence with the then CBSL Deputy Governors and senior Public Debt Department (PDD) officials, with the objective of raising funds to meet the unprecedentedly massive requirements of the government.
Manipulated the due process
ASG Dappula de Livera in his cross-examination of Mahendran said the former Governor had manipulated the due process, with an undisclosed motive in mind.
"I totally reject that," said Mahendran.
Suggesting that Mahendran had forcibly accompanied his two deputy governors, Dr. Nandalal Weerasinghe and Ananda Silva with him to the PDD the second time he is said to have visited it, de Livera said the evidence the two had given under oath was that neither of them knew where they were even going.
"We all agreed to go," countered Mahendran, explaining that his two deputies had come into his office "because we had a problem."
A sum of Rs 172 billion had to be raised in March 2015, and Mahendran, he claimed, did not have the "foggiest" idea on how the CBSL was going to do that. The witness claimed that he was expecting guidance from the deputy officers, adding that he had then suggested to them to go along with him to the PDD to see how much money the auction had raised.
De Livera, countered that, contrary to Mahendran's pronouncements, Rs 172 billion was not a big amount for the PDD to raise; but Mahendran insisted that, given the Bank's track record the previous two months via private placements, it was a "massive amount."
At this point, Commissioner Justice Prasanna Jayawardena inquired, since Mahendran could not have known how much had bid by way of private placements, if he had testified earlier that he discussed the small amounts raised (through private placements) in his office, would that testimony have been false. Mahendran agreed.
De Livera then recounted that, at the PDD, Mahendran was with the two deputy governors, then Superintendent of Public Debt Deepa Seneviratne and her two Additional Superintendents U. L. Muthugala and Dr. M. Z. M. Aazim. The Acting Solicitor General put to the former Governor that, once Superintendent Seneviratne had told him that some 20 billion had been received, he had instructed her to "take 20." Both Seneviratne and Dr. Aazim, said de Livera, had objected to their Governor's proposition.
Denying this, Mahendran claimed that Dr. Aazim had informed him that taking the whole 20 billion would've raised interest to unacceptable levels due to what is known in the trade as dummy bids – bids placed by primary dealers, according to Mahendran, at "ridiculously high" rates of interest when they don't wish their bids to be accepted. Dr. Aazim, he claimed, had said "we can take something reasonable."
Shock in the market
De Livera, however, maintained that the Additional Superintendent had argued with the Governor on the basis that accepting 20 billion would've created a shock in the market, to which, according to de Livera, Mahendran had said "take 10." "I don't recall that," responded Mahendran, reiterating that he had simply asked Dr. Aazim how much would've been a reasonable amount to accept.
When de Livera suggested that he had insisted on accepting 10 billion, Mahendran said he did not insist on the amount, but had simply asked Dr. Aazim to, once again, suggest a "reasonable" amount as the Central Bank had to raise Rs 13.5 billion by the following Monday.
De Livera then said Mahendran had told the PDD officials to go back to the pre-September 2014 rate and told PDD Superintendent Seneviratne to take 10 billion.
Mahendran denied this, claiming that he had said, "if I were you, I would accept 10 billion" to her and had walked off.
According to Mahendran's testimony yesterday, 13.5 billion was the realistic amount CBSL could've raised, given the fact that private placements had apparently not generated much. He claimed that Dr. Aazim had told him that if a line was drawn at the 10 billion mark, it would've been the rate at which the coupon equaled the highest bid – 12.5 per cent would correspond to the 12.5 per cent of the highest bid under10 billion. The weighted average rate of all the bids would be 11.73 per cent, he said, adding that he had then asked him what the weighted average rate of the previous 30-year bond auction held in May 2014 had been.
Solution must be acceptable to Tamils Separate State is not a reasonable request - Former Army Commander, General Gerry De Silva RWP, VSV, USP
- Beetle in Lankan tea shipment to Russia Exporter to be spared says Pethiyagoda
- Canadian Police probe ‘suspicious’ deaths of billionaire couple
- Stock Market Investor losses extend to Rs 94B
- Use of polythene in political rallies CEA to take on offenders
- Draft Legislation HRCSL advice not sought – UN Experts
- Drugs and drug users on the increase
- No NICs for 500,000 Lankans 300,000 are registered voters Bulk without birth certificates
- Growth decelerates to 3.3%
- UN damns Lanka 14,000 minors in childcare centres Calls for urgent reforms
- Russia restricts Lanka tea over beetle scare Top-level delegation off to Moscow
- Call to criminalize marital rape Justice Ministry seeks Cabinet approval
- Jumbo killings Armed protection unit to be set up Fines, jail terms to be increased
- Crossovers loom prior to polls
- SC issues notice on Elections Chief
- Jilted SLFP shuns JO forever
- CEB TU threatens strike Gives 18th as ultimatum
- Gnanasara Thera’s request for foreign travel denied
- Chinese envoy says OBOR will take Sino-Lanka ties to new level
- Police Chief in pre-poll warning Errant officers will be dealt with strictly
- Court extends Stay Order on Gota case
- Sriyani as State Minister of PCs and LG JO crossover pledged support for MS
- Rains to prevail Landslide warning to Galle, Kalutara to be reviewed
- BJP lauds ‘Ram Setu’ findings Hits out at critics
- Two held for impersonation at exam centre
- Female Genital Mutilation Advice sought from medical experts
- Visakhapatnam will favour the home team Batsmen to dominate decider
- Jadeja hits six sixes in an over
- Ntini’s son Thando in SA U-19 World Cup squad
- Neves stunner guides Wolves
- Westbrook nets triple double for Thunder
- Don’t see me making a WI comeback - Dwayne Bravo
- FIFA threatens to boot Spain out of World Cup
- SL lose two matches in T10s
- Army can dominate Air Force
- Smith and Marsh put attack to sword
- Sri Lanka play two Tests and Tri series in Bangladesh
- Chiefs winners in Kandy 10s
- Interesting battle at Havelock Park
- Thurstan win inaugural golf tourney
- History making Pulisic US men’s footballer of the year
- Knicks down Nets despite early exit for Porzingis
- 34th Mercantile Individual Tournament 2017 McLarens shuttlers Overall Champions
- Retired Hewitt takes tilt at Aussie Open doubles
- Lamborghini World Final 2017 Malagamuwa finishes third
- Committee clears Thilaka as SL coach
- Govt backtracks on anti-coal policy Two 600MW coal plants coming up
- Lankan company in pioneering global innovation
- Increasing worker remittances: Not a sign of prosperity
- Russian ban on Sri Lankan tea imports Navin to rush to Russia Ban comes into effect tomorrow, despite preventive efforts
- Dialog, RPC in CSE’s S&P SL20
- ADB loans Government US$ 270 million
- Japan expands unilateral sanctions against North Korea
- Purchasing Managers’ Index accelerates
- THASL educates Deputy Principals on Hospitality Management
- Financial Intelligence Unit signs MoU with Sri Lanka Police
- US Embassy & ICTA organize Knowledge Sharing Session
- CIM announces 2017 Board of Trustees CIM to be headed by leading marketing talent from across the industry
- Bolstering tourism: Starting from the top
- HNB wins two at CA Sri Lanka Annual Report Awards 2017
- Subhash Pinnapola launches ‘Storybook’ creative agency
- Mother Sri Lanka Movement launches series of activities
- Assets for debt, a flawed strategy
- Envisioning the future of Digital Banking
- Bank of Ceylon launches digital passbook
- Siyapatha Finance opens new branch in Panadura
- Protect Wilpattu Movement set in motion 5K strong turnout march in peaceful protest to UN office & handover petition
- Concretes & Abstracts Faith, Wayside Shrines & Urban Sprawl
- TGTE using Lawyers to challenge SL’s 6th amendment
- Christmas cheer is in the air!
- So, this is Christmas!
- New Land Draft BiLL Political wrangling hinders ironing out complex land issues
- We (don’t) need a Messiah Champika has failed to maintain what Mangala designed and Gota delivered
- M12M on the campaign trail Spotlight on polls and criminal elements
- Lord Naseby vs the Sri Lanka Campaign War is over, but body count debate continues
- Women’s quota in LG elections Historic opportunity Elect qualified, capable women– not wives & relatives of thugs
- Maithri should not sit in a Cabinet sans SLFPers
- Wigneswaran sowing seeds of communalism
- SLFP supports devolution of power – Lasantha Alagiyawanna
- If Bond scammers are not prosecuted…President will lose his credibility –Bandula Gunawardena
- All information security issues are not cyber crimes
- Sirisena Presidency - A Parallax View As foretold by Sobhitha Hamuduruwo
- Blessed are the peacemakers
- Disinformation campaigns and public mistrust
- Kemadruma Yoga An evil yoga cancelling all other favourable yogas
- Sun into Sagittarius ‘Kona Month’ has just begun
- Inviting wrath of goddess Lakshmi
- Five Yoga Poses to Calm Your Mind
- Rahu in 7th House and marriage
- The Disaster Artist: The (un)making of a movie
- Our children and our cinema
- INTERPRETING ASIAN CINEMA: CHALLENGES AHEAD
- How Sanskrit journalism is slowly hogging headlines
- ice manufacturing in South Asia
- CMSC’s season finale concert
- Two documentaries on Sri Lanka in Film South Asia 2017
- Politics of nostalgia
- Kite Surfing Lanka Kalpitiya An experience of a lifetime
- Ella and mini Adam’s Peak
- A cave of history -Ravana Cave
- I don’t get asked out
- Homemade apple & Chocolate Bodywash
- THE WRITER’S KITCHENETTE HOW THE GRINCH STOLE CHRISTMAS CUPCAKES Grinch Cupcakes
- New York Blast Terror charges filed against NY bomber
- Saga of Kohukumbure Rate Rala
- Attygalle murder and John Kotelawala Senior’s suicide