Electoral Reforms are for People’s Benefit
By Faiszer Musthapha
(Minister of Provincial Councils and Local Government)
Very recently, my Ministry successfully passed an amendment to the Provincial Councils Election Act. Ever since then, reasonable concerns were raised in respect of the manner in which it was passed. I believe some of these concerns ought to be dispelled before the positive nature of the amendment falls into question. It is first and foremost important to note the crucial changes to the Act. Firstly, there shall be a quota allocating a guaranteed 25% of the seats to women in all Provincial Councils. In the past, we have seen a very low turnout of women in politics. Only 5.8% of the Parliamentary seats are allocated to women and as of 2013 statistics, only 3.9% of Provincial Councils were comprised women.
Even in the past it has been no different. As of 2004, women comprised only 5% of the seats in Provincial Councils, and in 1999 women comprised only 3.2% of the seats.
It is also important to note that 80% of those women who have been elected to power until now emerge from political backgrounds. Any other woman who seeks to enter the fold of politics is usually deterred and undermined, usually by the media and the patriarchal and politically misogynistic male politicians. Most women prefer avoiding politics in order to maintain a better environment for their families to advance, without having to involve in dirty politics.
However, in this day and age, it cannot be denied that women play a crucial role in politics around the World and their roles have substantially contributed towards political betterment. In 1995, the Fourth World Conference on Women in Beijing introduced the suggestion of guaranteeing 30% women representation in National Governments. Today, the Governments that implemented these measures have reached a higher pedestal in politics.
Simply consider Angela Merkel of Germany, Theresa May of United Kingdom, Christina Fernandez of Argentina or even Sheikh Hasina Wazed of Bangladesh among many others. Even in the corporate World, there have been many companies that have thrived with women at the helm. Consider Sheryl Sandberg, the CEO of Facebook, or Meg Whitman, the CEO of Hewlett Packard, or Indra Nooyi, the CEO of PepsiCo or even Sri Lanka's own Otara Gunawardene, the Founding CEO of ODEL and Dr. Radhika Coomaraswamy, a member of the Constitutional Council now and the former Under Secretary-General of the United Nations. They have proved over a period of time that women can be excellent leaders.
Women- headed households
To those of you that feel that women play an essential role in their respective households, let me point out to you that Sri Lanka has had 24.2% of women- headed households. If women can successfully head their own households, what prevents them from successfully leading this country?
Apart from these reasons, women bring many qualities to the table. They are natural caretakers, and their ideas and perspectives on politics may differ from the male perspective. A female contribution is essential to achieve gender parity in politics, law and employment, and together we may uplift Sri Lanka to greater heights.
The Mixed Member Proportional System is undeniably another welcome change to the electoral system we introduced through the Provincial Councils Elections (Amendment) Act. This was originally the recommendation of Hon. Dinesh Gunawardena, leader of the Mahajana Eksath Peramuna (MEP) who sits in the Opposition, and his Committee. Thence it became a promise of His Excellency President Hon. Maithripala Sirisena through his election manifesto.
The Provincial Council Elections Act seeks to introduce a change to the electoral process by electing 50% of Provincial Council Members through the First Past the Post system and 50% of the members through the Proportional Representation system.
Throughout the history of post-independence politics in Sri Lanka, the citizens have observed the best and worst of the First Past the Post system and the Proportional Representation system. Until 1977, Sri Lanka had the First Past the Post system which was cost effective, less violent and elected a representative of a particular region from a particular region, which meant that if a representative did not fulfil the desires of his people, the people could vote for a different representative at the next election. It also allowed for single party Governments, which meant party policies did not have to be watered down. The opposition is equally vibrant in such a system too.
However, the First Past the Post system had its flaws. Territorial representation meant that there was a possibility of bias and that minorities could be prejudiced. Minority parties, in particular, that do not fully conform to the values of majority parties, would be easily side-lined in such a system. It also leaves a large number of wasted votes. For example, in 1970, the SLFP won only 48% of the votes and still acquired 76.7% of the seats in Parliament and in 1977, the UNP won only 50.6% of the votes and acquired 83% of the seats in Parliament.
The flaws gave rise to the Proportional Representation system beginning from the 1978 Constitution. The Proportional Representation system had its advantages. It ensured minority representation and accommodated smaller parties, which introduced joint policies. There was stronger bargaining power as a result, and votes were rarely wasted.
However, the Proportional Representation system also came with shortfalls. It required greater campaign budgets, and violence escalated between political rivals. There is also a racial stigma attached to it. As we have seen in the recent past, racial tendencies tend to rise under this system. The election expenditure is also significantly greater than under the First Past the Post system.
Therefore, the Mixed Member Proportional system was born combining the best of both Worlds. Most people are in favour of this system, and it is truly in the interests of justice and democracy that I believe this is the way forward.
While I honestly believe the bill carries very positive steps approaching the foreseeable future, there has been significant concerns regarding the procedure followed in enacting the law. The Standing Orders of Parliament make it very clear that it is permissible to pass an amendment during the Committee Stage of a bill.
Standing Order 56 reads, "Any amendment may be made to a clause, or clauses may be deleted or new clauses may be added, provided the same be relevant to the subject matter of the Bill, and be otherwise in conformity with the Standing Orders".
The additional clauses in respect of the electoral system was added upon a request by minority parties. This is the reason why many of the minority parties, including the Tamil National Alliance, supported this amendment. Although a few people are opposed to this move, it is my belief that those very people are opposed to every positive move emerging from this Government as it would build goodwill among the people.
Certain entities were uncomfortable with the idea of passing it in haste. I wish to comment that it could have been better for us to initiate a dialogue and obtain a consensus prior to bringing in this amendment at Committee Stage dealing with the Mixed Member Proportional System.However, political expediency required the passage of this amendment to introduce electoral reforms. It would not have been prudent to have the Provincial Councils under the Proportional Representation system and the rest after passing the amendment for the Mixed Member Proportional system.
There was no necessity to be hasty, as the procedure was well within the law and a very welcome piece of legislation that would only help this country progress. However, delimitation would require time and effort, and if there is a lesson we have learnt in the recent past, it is what delays in delimitation can cost us.
There is an urgent requirement now to commence a delimitation commission on this subject, and there is also a need to encourage deserving and capable women to participate in politics if this initiative is to be truly fruitful. Now that the requisite changes have been passed in law, we must carry forward the positive efforts without glancing backwards and ensure that our political future is in secure hands.
We must evaluate from the perspective of the Committee Stage Amendment in the interests of democracy, keeping in mind the recommendations of the Dinesh Gunawardena Select Committee report and the pledge of His Excellency President Hon.Maithripala Sirisena who promised that he would introduce the Mixed Member Proportional system to address the prevailing issues under the current electoral system.
- Quo Vadis, China?
- Why Americans are no longer dynamic
- Pardon and release the 158 Tamil remand prisoners
- Workshops to develop tourism in the East
- SWOAD promotes rights of migrant workers
- PAFFREL seeks Gazetting of Elections Amendment Bill
- CMB Port City: Work will be completed by 2019– Sagala Ratnayaka
- AKD’s RTI request from TRC pending a reply
- Alliance Française gets new library & information corner
- Give more women & youth a chance – March 12 Movt
- SL and Pakistan to consolidate bilateral relations
- Missing girls surrender to Police Three charged with abduction
- Amaraweera claims life in danger
- For energy security SL to enter into agreement with Qatar
- Sex spray puts 3 girls in hospital
- JVP to sue Johnnie for Rs 500 M
- Hosting SAARC Summit Pakistan assured of SL’s support
- International Conventions and Debasement of Legislative Process Part II
- Developing education sector Will take tough decisions – Akila Viraj
- Guangzhou looking for investment opportunities – Tu Hongze
- Three women go missing in Orugodawatte
- Awareness on violence against women Mahela and Kumar address students
- Foreign Secretary’s visit to Sri Lanka Pakistan commits to stronger ties
- Sashi to take Ranjan to Court
- allegedly defrauded more than Rs 100mn Employment fraudster remanded
- Kusal Perera ruled out from Pakistan T20Is
- De Villiers hits thrilling century
- Sri Lanka ‘A’ tour of West Indies 2nd Four day match starts today
- Sluggish Sri Lanka move slowly
- ‘Singer Cup’ U-19 Schools Cricket St. John’s Jaffna create major upset
- SL women’s tour of WIndies T20 matches start today
- Sri Lanka approaching Pakistan visit cautiously
- Wattala Antonian Sixes 2017 this weekend
- Golf ‘really healthy’ even without Tiger, says Rose
- Lanka Lions Tag Rugby Sevens Trinity wins cup for fifth time in UAE
- TTSC Softball Cricket ‘Sixes’ 2017 51 Men’s, 7 Women’s teams battle for honours
- Kuldeep cements place in Indian attack
- SL out to save series Batsmen aren’t fulfilling their responsibilities - Managers and Coach Kapugedera likely to play today
- Gunathilaka’s ban revised - SLC Ex-Co
- Sadeera to be included in ODI team
- 130 SRI LANKA AMATEUR GOLF CHAMPIONSHIP 2017 at NUWARA ELIYA Chalitha Pushpika topples indian top seed Sri Lanka 3 out of 4 in SEMI-FINAL
- ‘Singer Cup’ U-19 Schools Cricket Kamindu Mendis scores third ton
- Royal regain E.F.C. Pereira Challenge Trophy
- DSI Supersport Schools Volleyball Championship 2017 Finals just around the corner
- All Blacks coach backs Sonny Bill Williams
- SL remains too protectionist
- Govt. aims $1.6B FDI next year, $2B in 2019
- 70% growth from consumption and investment
- ADB debuts risk sharing to support trade in developing Asia
- SL GDP to grow 7% from 2020 - Mangala
- Retail sector asks for Govt support to boost retail tourism
- Dr. coom in for good times!
- ‘Excon 2017’ Road Show to highlight SL construction sector
- Sri Lanka impresses investors in New York
- West Coast beach front soaring in value
- Asia markets tread water Investors scrutinize China’s Party Congress
- SL among Asia’s fastest adopters of cloud computing
- Hosted by Sri Lanka-China Business Cooperation Council
- Toyota Lanka contributes Hybrid Learning Centre to AETI
- Value of social networking yet to be determined
- Sri Lanka to inaugurate performance art center for tourists
- Guangzhou Govt representatives positive about investing
- Lanka Hospitals & Sri Lanka Heart Association to mark World Heart Day
- BBDO Lanka strikes gold at Effies
- Sampath Bank celebrates ‘Thrift Month’ with eco-friendly gifts
- Implications of Provincial Police Departments
- Cairo: Most dangerous megacity for women
- Proxy Waiting
- Shortage of Science Graduates
- Rice Revolution Simply a Catalyst or more…?
- Fall of Raqqa
- UN urges B’desh to move Rohingya refugees
- Flu shots are the greatest medical fraud in the history of the world
- Sucking it up
- Ahikuntika community of Sri Lanka Diminishing cultural traits
- Even the PM should be in Prison for the frauds
- Would like more Pradeshiya Sabhas for N’Eliya-Radhakrishnan
- Skills mismatch a massive economic cost Education system must be reformed
- Federalism is the antithesis of separatism Wiggy
- Kiriella has no right to ask me not to speak-Handunnetti
- UNHRC Resolution 30/1 Implications for Sri Lanka (Part II) (Based on a presentation to the OPA)
- Electoral Reforms are for People’s Benefit
- Managing perception with international community
- Salient points of horoscope Assessment
- KARMIC CONNECTIONS IN THE BIRTH CHARTS 2
- Dream of travelling abroad?
- Mystery behind Osama bin Laden explained
- Three poses to relieve trauma
- Socio-economic developments from critical perspective
- KAZUO ISHIGURO – THE NEW NOBEL LAUREATE
- The Fairway Galle Literary Festival 2018 –Internationally acclaimed authors to take part
- Portrayal of country and nature
- Resonant Field Imaging - a Marvel in Technology
- Shankar’s International Children’s Competition 2018
- Hindustani Violin recital
- Classical rendering of a masterly-crafted musical
- Kite Surfing Lanka Kalpitiya An experience of a lifetime
- Ella and mini Adam’s Peak
- A cave of history -Ravana Cave
- Making plus-sized clothing trendy
- Pyjamas go viral as well - Sharmila Srikumar
- Giving back to Society
- Double treat at Pinnawala
- Mental illness a health issue Replacing stigma with compassion
- Studying to be ahead