Catalonia separatists crisis worsen
By Marianne Barriaux
As Catalonia's separatist crisis drags on, Spain's judiciary has found itself on the back foot, accused of engaging in the type of partisanship normally associated with repressive dictatorships. The region's sacked leader Carles Puigdemont says he is in Belgium because he would not get fair treatment back home, a claim only amplified when eight of his deputies were jailed last week pending investigation into charges of sedition and rebellion.
But while legal experts have criticised some aspects of the judicial response to Catalonia's independence drive, they reject claims that the system lacks independence.
Manuel Ruiz de Lara, spokesman for the advocacy group Civic Platform for Judiciary Independence, defends the independence of judges' decisions which he notes are often criticised or approved by politicians "according to their interests".
He says that if politicians like a decision they proclaim it the work of an independent judge, and vice-versa if they are opposed to it. The Catalan crisis, which kicked off when separatist leaders held an independence referendum last month despite a court ban, has stoked passions in Spain.
Portrayed as a repressive state by supporters of secession, Spain was also accused of taking "political prisoners" when a Madrid judge sent the leaders of two Catalan pro-independence associations to prison pending investigation into sedition.
Last week, the same judge jailed eight Catalan regional ministers who had been sacked by Madrid.
By then, Puigdemont and four of his deputies had fled to Belgium.
In her ruling remanding the eight in custody, Judge Carmen Lamela decided among other things that it was too risky to set them free during the investigation as they could escape, given Puigdemont and others had already done so. Her decision caused outrage.
"Spanish justice has been placed at the service of the government's political agenda," wrote Puigdemont, who awaits possible extradition, in the UK's Guardian newspaper.
Still, while some question whether Lamela made the right decision, judges and legal experts believe she made it free of political influence.
"Judges are independent. That they may at times not be reasonable or sensible is another thing," says Xavier Arbos, a law professor at the University of Barcelona.
Rebellion charge in doubt
However, the charge of rebellion brought against separatist leaders, which in this case could be punishable by up to 25 years in jail, has drawn controversy.
Defined as "rising up in a violent and public manner," it is "disproportionate" according to Jose Maria Mena, a former chief prosecutor in Catalonia, given the peaceful nature of the independence drive.
Spain's chief prosecutor argues that independence supporters repeatedly intimidated and resisted police forces, which he says constitutes a form of violence.
For Mena, though, that equates to converting "social pressure generated by any protest in a democratic country... into rebellion". "I don't know if he spoke to (Prime Minister Mariano) Rajoy before, it's very unlikely," he says. But "the chief prosecutor thought that if he was very severe, the independence movement would weaken, which was an extra-judicial calculation".
The perception that Spain's judiciary is biased has long simmered across the country – not just in Catalonia.
In the EU's 2017 "Justice Scoreboard," Spain came third to last among 28 member states where public perception of the independence of judges and courts is concerned, behind Slovakia and Bulgaria.
"That really hurts," says Celso Rodriguez Padron, a magistrate in Madrid and spokesman for the Magistrates' Professional Association.
"I've had the opportunity to deal with penal cases where people from the political world were involved and I can guarantee it doesn't matter, a politician is judged with exactly the same criteria as anyone else," he says.
Lamela may have decided to jail Catalan separatists, he adds, but other judges have over the years remanded former members of the ruling conservative Popular Party (PP) in custody in various corruption cases.
Rodriguez says the negative perception may stem from Spain's General Council of the Judiciary (CGPJ), a powerful body in charge of appointing judges to the Supreme Court as well as presidents of high and regional courts.
In the 1980s a majority of the 20-member council was appointed by judges and the rest by parliament, but now the whole body is selected by the lower and upper houses.
"Judges have always asked that we return to the original system to stop people from believing that if the authority that governs the judiciary is appointed by political groups, then naturally those political groups will choose judges that agree with their ideas," says Rodriguez.
Critics say politics – and whichever parties hold sway at the moment – are deeply rooted in the nation's legal system.
And they also point to the nation's Constitutional Court, whose judges are put forward by the government, parliament and the CGPJ -- the court that declared the Catalan referendum illegal.
AFP Caption : A man wearing an Catalan pro-independence 'Estelada' flag as a mask attends a demonstration outside the Generalitat Palace in Barcelona
- Maldives:President Yameen’s relationship with India and the US
- (UN)TRAFFICKED: A platform to combat trafficking in India
- IDPs and Military occupation of Northern land Why correlation between caste and land is ignored
- Three die as car rams into train
- KG discovery in Point Pedro sea 150kg in 60 bags - Navy
- Symposium on alcohol menace
- Tax concessions on used electric cars Extend period to three years – VIASL
- Refusal to hoist National Flag Cooray to seek AG’s opinion
- Gintota mayhem Police to crackdown on rumour mongers
- Lanka Marine Services scandal Vasu flays Govt for delay in probe
- Dedicated Courts to hear sleaze cases Start with Bond issue says JVP
- O/L exam to commence on 12 December
- Ajith P. Perera writes to PCoI Denies conversing with Aloysius
- In the wake of violence Gintota divided into 3 for security – Police Preventable if Police acted sooner -IGP
- Fuel Crisis Hoax CPC goes to the CID
- Only 10 detained under PTA Govt Suspects held on serious terror charges
- Speaker agrees to summon Party Leaders’ meeting Kiriella claims breach of Parliamentary privileges occurred Blames CID and AG’s Dept
- PCoI quashes tapping allegations
- Treasury Bonds Probe PM told Aloysius to resign from PTL
- India’s Choice: Saintliness Vs Efficiency
- Commercial Credit Japanese Firm moves in
- Man shot dead at Punchi Borella
- SAITM still exists, claims GMFSPA Group to meet Maha Sangha
- Lanka tour operators to visit Pakistan
- Fake sms on petrol shortage again! Leads to panic buying in Kandy
- ‘Singer Cup’ Under-19 Schools Cricket 20 wickets fall on day one
- Kohli scores 50th international century Bad light saves Sri Lanka
- I want to continue contributing - Kohli
- England motivated as ever even without Stokes
- Wimbledon champion Jana Novotna dies aged 49: WTA
- CMSC – Come and Try Day Out Ranjit Jinasena Memorial Autocross
- Cook captures maiden PGA Tour title
- Walkers Tours regain tag rugby title
- Dialog Champions League 2017 Renown SC occupy top spot
- Record-breaking Valencia maintain Barca chase
- Dimitrov eyes Grand Slam after ATP win
- Bolt to make Aussie cricketers ‘explosive’ runners
- Kandy SC in runaway win
- SLC clarifies Dilruwan’s actions
- India take 49 run lead
- Six-year-old wins two Silvers in shooting events
- Renown rout Blue Stars 4-0
- MAS Unichela emerge champions
- Senkadagala Rally
- Air Force SC in 15-7 win over Police SC
- NITFB settles flood of claims in 2017
- CSE approves LVL Energy Fund IPO
- SLT posts 9- month revenue of Rs 56.4 B
- EU cities fight to gain from London’s losses
- CCC says Pak capitalized while SL dilly dallied
- Asian shares retreat on German coalition impasse
- Alibaba aims beyond China and e-commerce
- FX Management Act flays rupee
- National Chamber Seminar on ‘Budget 2018 – Highlights’
- Canada, Mexico to question US auto content demands
- Brandix JV with Best Pacific, Hong Kong
- Hemas Hospitals Thalawathugoda concludes diabetes awareness drive
- Unilever and MullenLowe most awarded partnership at Effies
- MBSL wins International Europe Award for Quality 2017
- SLIM hosts 16th Brand Excellence Awards
- Asia markets mixed as investors focus on US tax reform
- China’s promised 2030 energy revolution
- Will Europe’s economic miracle be derailed by a central-bank power struggle?
- Meet the world’s youngest self-made billionaire
- Flooding the market with fake rhino horns
- TNA crisis Enmity within
- The March of Folly Restitution with transparency rather than revenge
- The National Flag A Muddled Tamil voice
- Rohingya children Face a bleak future
- New Constitution:National perspective versus political aspirations
- China and Vietnam: Beyond Diplomacy
- Middle East: Kurdish Pawn Sacrificed
- Concretes and abstracts Two comics at the Savoy in London
- Row over beer tax
- Illegal mining Muttur’s sandy secret Hundreds of tons of sand taken away at night
- Eastern Provincial Council destroyed- Hafiz
- eLECTRIC AND HYBRID CARS MUST BE PRICED REASONABLY
- Wigneswaran’s claim Devanampiya Tissa was a Tamil king An academically naïve proposition Prof Raj Somadeva
- There is no journey with the UNP
- Core values of the UNP are eroding - Pradeep Jayewardene
- An argument for a new Constitution
- ‘Otriachchi’, ‘Orumiththa Nadu’, ‘Aekeeya Rajya’ and unitary state
- A Constitutional Framework for Sri Lanka
- PAST LIFE AND RULING PLANETS IN KRISHNAMURTHI PADHDHATHI
- Build before onset of Kona Masa
- Palms of road accident victims
- Want to get rid of malefic Saturn ?
- Installing doors and windows according to Vastu
- Our children and our cinema
- INTERPRETING ASIAN CINEMA: CHALLENGES AHEAD
- How Sanskrit journalism is slowly hogging headlines
- ice manufacturing in South Asia
- CMSC’s season finale concert
- Two documentaries on Sri Lanka in Film South Asia 2017
- Politics of nostalgia
- Vibrancy of classical Sinhala poetry
- Kite Surfing Lanka Kalpitiya An experience of a lifetime
- Ella and mini Adam’s Peak
- A cave of history -Ravana Cave
- Conquering Fashion
- Gavin Ryan’s Salon Professionalism to the next level
- THE WRITER’S KITCHENETTE THE CRANBERRY ADVENTURES
- Calamitous Earthquake in Iran
- Scientists warn of ‘giant leap backward’ at climate talks
- Death of Ananda Senaratne