Regional and Constitutional Practices in Asia Exploring the ambiguous
By Priyangwada Perera
"We look at it, and do not see it; it is invisible. We listen to it and do not hear it; it is inaudible. We touch it, and do not feel it; it is intangible. These three elude our inquiries, and hence merge into one", says the Eastern philosopher Lao Tzu. It is tempting to quote this in a different context. Different eastern religions and philosophies have contributed and influenced Asian culture and politics.
Oblivious to the general understanding, it can be argued that there is a strong undercurrent of religion in each of the constitutional practices in Asian countries.
The Centre for Asian Legal Studies (CALS) and the International Centre for Ethnic Studies (ICES) came together to host a paper presentation and discussion on Religion and Constitutional Practices in Asia. It was held at the International Centre for Ethnic Studies, on the 9 and 10 of November.
It is the lack of knowledge, lack of information and our inability to base our arguments on concrete facts that often give rise to prejudices. The programme continued for two days with four panel discussions on the first day. They were themed Islam and the Constitution, Buddhism and the Constitution, Religion and 'Secular' Constitutions and Law and Policy. Dr. Matthew Nelson from SOAS, University of London was the first to speak on Amending Pakistan's (Islamic) Constitution: Electoral vs. Judicial Power. Dr. Nelson stressed on the essential features of a Constitution that cannot be amended. He brought forward a comparison between the Indian and the Pakistani Constitutions. Dr. Nelson termed them 'remarkably similar, yet totally different.' The question was whether Sri Lanka is an outlier.
Dr. Shamshad Pasarlay, Assistant Professor at Herat University School of Law and Political Sciences spoke of the Role of Islam in Afghanistan. Based on their Constitution making from 1880 to 1901, Dr. Pasarlay discussed the absence of 'one original Islam' in Afghanistan. The more dividing than the unifying aspect of Islam, which was different from community to community was presented right from 1880s to 2004 where Afghanistan adopted its 1st Constitution of the 21st century.
The paper on Religion, Child Conversions and Custody Battles in Malaysia was presented by Dr. Dian A. H. Shah of National University of Singapore author of Constitutions, Religion and politics in Asia, Indonesia, Malaysia and Sri Lanka. The problematic issue of having to appear in Sharia Courts where a Hindu mother has no standing was brought to light. Associate Prof. Arif Jamal from National University of Singapore spoke of the importance of the contextual practise.
Gehan Gunatilleke, a human rights lawyer and researcher, pursuing DPhil (PhD) at the University of Oxford, focussed on Sri Lanka. The ethno religious violence in the 2015 era was discussed. Highlighting violence divided into chronic, acute and structural forms, Gunatilleke argued that statistics suggest that violence has not changed despite the change of Governments. His question was why our legal system has not been strong enough to fight this. Does the Constitution support ethno religious violence? We are socialized to believe that Sri Lanka is a Sinhala Buddhist country. Gunatilleke's explanation of the misreading of 'sasana', which is no longer the 'teaching' but 'Buddhist community'. The problematic function of Sangha declaring themselves the 'protectors of Buddhism' and wherever violence is instigated the mediation of Sangha restricts the law were addressed.
Dr. NyiNyiKyaw from Myanmar discussed how Buddhism has been the religion of the State since the 9th Century. There were non-Buddhists who contributed to the freedom struggle, but nobody questioned the decision of the then insanely popular Aung San who was the father of Aung San Suu Kyi, when he made Buddhism the State religion. He also discussed the anti-Muslim Buddhist nationalism post-2013 where Buddhism re-established itself as the 'host', and the others as the outsiders, where Christianity and Islam were considered guests. Post Doctoral Fellow Eugenie Mérieau came out with her vast knowledge and understanding of Buddhist Constitutionalism in Thailand. What Mérieau called the 'Buddhistization of legal thought', Buddhist kingship and how good governance was considered inferior to the 2000 plus years old Buddhist forms of 10 Royal Virtues of a Righteous King were spoken in terms of Natural Law and Legal Law.
Prof. Benjamin Schonthal brought out a fine discourse on Religious Law and Public Law. He further discussed about religious authority and State legal authority; and the concept of Raja Dharma and Dharma Raja, where Dharma also becomes the law. How 'Buddistization of law' tends to happen. Prof. Schonthal spoke in terms of reconciling the interest of two groups of authority.
Associate Prof. Ameya Balsekar, who spoke on Gandhian philosophy to the Indian Constitution and quoted the British economist Joan Robinson who said "Whatever you can rightly say about India, the opposite is also true," Prof. Balsekar expressed his passionately delivered sentiments, and facts on nationalism that is so unique to the process of the Indian Constitution making.
Shamsul Falaah from Maldives spoke on Islamic Constitutionalism in the Maldives, where a Maldivian should be a Muslim. Dr. Radhika Coomaraswamy brought out how most countries in the world cater to one religion. She referred to religion as "The skeleton under the flesh." Her differentiation was that most of the issues reported are not constitutional but criminal justice issues.
Prof. Andrew Harding drew a fine parallel between division and the British introduction of Cricket to India. It was never the British Vs. India that got divided. India was divided in terms of Hindu, Muslim or Parsi teams. He discussed the self contradiction of the nature of 'freedom of religion'. Prof. Harding insisted that giving one religion constitutional provision of primacy essentially discriminates another. He questioned the need of calling God by one specific name. Dr. Asanga Welikala looked at the thought of a 'perfect Constitution' that can address 'life that is imperfect'. Where he saw a 'perfect Nation State' as unachievable; his argument was that equality should be abandoned in favour of pluralism.
It was half in jest that Benjamin Schonthal mentioned his brother's reaction when he heard Ben has authored "Law and religion in Sri Lanka, who cares about that?," In preparation for writing 'Buddhism, Politics and the Limits of Law: The Pyrrhic Constitutionalism of Sri Lanka'; Ben had wanted to find a book, a story that could tell him about law, a history that came through ethnography, interviews and so on. But he could not find that book. "I hope we wrote the book I could not find," he concluded.
Ministry Secretaries should be appointed on Best interest of Public not Minister Lethargy blocking change
- An Inconsistent US Assertive China and Asia’s Hobbesian Order
- Jorge Sharp and Citizen Movements:New Momentum for Chilean Left?
- Zimbabwe’s Tailspin: The Lessons for Africa
- Lankan family facing deportation due to MS diagnosis
- Malaysian security forces in SL Undergo sea combat training
- Customs nabs man with gold jewellery
- Pushpadana celebrates 75 years Educational rights for all children - President
- New Samurdhi officers appointed
- Removal of Thondaman’s name India to take up issue with SL
- Int’l Research Conference held at SEUSL
- Three PTA detainees:Solution can be expected on 29 Nov TELO
- Call to promote tourism in East
- Corruption in mega development projects:Revelations soon - Dr. Jayalath
- President Sirisena writes to Lord Naseby Expresses appreciation for furthering SL’s cause
- Non-alignment of Budget proposals Tax consultants complain Chartered accountants highlight exclusion of professionals
- Dr. Nandalal Weerasinghe to deliver Olcott Oration
- Sujeewa and Namal in verbal spat
- Budget 2018 2nd reading passed with 2/3rd majority
- MR issues call to send Govt packing
- Sampanthan flays Rajapaksa Makes emotional plea in House
- Petitioners in LG polls gazette case Yapa, Dayasiri and Dilan among the six - JO
- Treasury Bonds Probe Ranil to appear before PCoI on Monday
- Five COPE members spoke with Aloysius during their sittings
- Harsha speaks at UPR Emphasizes slow and steady approach
- LG Elections gazette petition CA to hear petition on 22 November
- Sevens players given SLR contracts 20 men and 16 women players will be signed on starting November
- ‘Singer Cup’ U-19 Cricket Sanjula gets 150 runs
- Lakmal rattles India on rain-hit day
- Curious case of Sri Lanka Winter Sports Association
- Inter Club Rugby League Tournament CR clash with arch rivals CH today
- All-Island School Games Table Tennis Ladies’ College Under 17 Champions
- Peru capture last World Cup berth
- Mohammad Hafeez, suspended again
- Ten weightlifters qualify for CG 2018
- Late Dalmiya’s 77th birth commemoration SLC President pays glowing tribute
- Serena Williams set to tie the knot in New Orleans
- World Anti-Doping Agency Refuses lifting Russia suspension
- 34th Mercantile Athletic Championships Sampath Bank Bags Third Place
- India want Sri Lanka to make them ‘uncomfortable’ Kohli Mathews gives us confidence as a batting unit - Chandimal
- Rajeew Perera appointed Junior Rugby coach
- Dialog Champions League Moragasmulla shocks Blue Star
- France to stage 2023 Rugby World Cup
- Minister confident Hathurusinghe will agree
- Will Dulakshi be elevated to Asian-Indoor podium ?
- AIBA Youth Women’s World Boxing C’ships TWO VILLAGE SCHOOLGIRLS FOR YOUTH WORLD MEET
- Asia Property Awards in Singapore Capital TRUST Residencies wins Best Condo in SL
- Lanka IOC reports losses for 3rd consecutive quarter
- Airtel and Google debut online purchasing in SL
- AIA Insurance Lanka revenue up 17% in Q3
- Full day of CSE trading from Disaster Recovery site
- Introducing Mars to agriculture
- How an oil giant came to dominate wheat
- Asian Shares Higher Ahead Of US Tax Vote
- Going green needs defined regulations to go forward
- Alibaba's Jack Ma slips to 3rd in China rich list
- Apple iPhone 8 and 8 Plus in Sri Lanka soon
- COMBANK cardholders get discounts up to 55%
- Regional Chamber alleges SMEs mere ornaments for Finance Ministers
- First ever Sri Lankan appointed Student Council VP at Manipal
- Sadaharitha Plantations wins at NASCO 2017
- New vehicle tax system the right move?
- Russia and Venezuela agree debt deal
- Mattala Airport talks this month
- State entities blocking digital documents
- Hilton and Grand Hyatt divestments soon
- LAW OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE
- Dual Citizenship Fiasco
- LAW OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE Part XIX Joinder of Charges VI
- The March of Folly The sad death of liberal Karu
- Saudi-led coalition opens Yemen border crossing: Aid agencies warn of famine
- BREXIT Impact on free movement of people
- Padmavati triggers stir in Bollywood
- Military burning houses Rohingya refugees flee to Bangladesh
- Rice Revolution Role of Dairy Centres
- Pollution in India: 2.5 million people killed in 2015
- There is no journey with the UNP
- Core values of the UNP are eroding - Pradeep Jayewardene
- UN compensation for Kuwait workers Rs 3.2 B on migrant worker welfare
- Professor Matteo Legrenzi says: Gulf States are not keen on all-out war
- I regret the inconvenience caused to the public
- An argument for a new Constitution
- ‘Otriachchi’, ‘Orumiththa Nadu’, ‘Aekeeya Rajya’ and unitary state
- A Constitutional Framework for Sri Lanka
- PAST LIFE AND RULING PLANETS IN KRISHNAMURTHI PADHDHATHI
- Astrological remedies for Agriculture
- Unintentional Murder and law
- An Idyl in South India
- GRANDMA’S HAIR GROWTH OIL
- INTERPRETING ASIAN CINEMA: CHALLENGES AHEAD
- How Sanskrit journalism is slowly hogging headlines
- ice manufacturing in South Asia
- CMSC’s season finale concert
- Two documentaries on Sri Lanka in Film South Asia 2017
- Politics of nostalgia
- Vibrancy of classical Sinhala poetry
- Gazing at the 'gems' of Sri Lanka
- Kite Surfing Lanka Kalpitiya An experience of a lifetime
- Ella and mini Adam’s Peak
- A cave of history -Ravana Cave
- Man who rebelled against the British
- Rohingya kids fill void of parents
- Looking back at Sri Lanka Police